Is OpenBrokers Real? Streamline Your Trading
The intriguing question of whether brokers open real positions or not has been a prevalent one in the trading community. This query arises due to the common use of brokers in forex and derivative markets, where they act as intermediaries between traders and liquidity providers. However, the answer to this question isn't black and white and can vary depending on the type of brokerage, the trading platform, and the specific trading conditions.
At its core, a 'real' position in trading refers to a genuine transaction in the underlying asset, occurring in the interbank market or a major exchange. On the other hand, traders often deal with 'pseudo' or 'fake' positions in the retail market, depending on their broker.
Straight-Through Processing (STP) Brokers
STP brokers, also known as 'no dealing desk' brokers, provide clients with direct market access. This means that STP brokers route client orders straight to liquidity providers, thereby opening real positions in the market.
When trading with an STP broker, your trades are not executed against the broker's internal position. Instead, they are passed on to liquidity providers, who facilitate the trade in the actual market. This model ensures that STP brokers cannot manipulate trades or act as a market maker.
Benefits of STP Brokers
STP brokers offer several advantages, such as low spreads, high liquidity, and the ability to trade without conflict of interest. The ECN/STP model also permits traders to use expert advisors (EAs) and scalping strategies, making it popular among algorithmic traders.
However, it's crucial to note that STP brokers might charge a commission on top of the spread, and they may not be suitable for all trading styles. For instance, beginner traders might prefer fixed spreads and no commission structure.
Drawbacks of STP Brokers
Despite their benefits, STP brokers have some drawbacks. They can be less forgiving to new traders due to their variable spreads, and they require traders to manage their own risk effectively. Moreover, the ECN/STP model can involve higher slippage compared to market maker brokers during volatile market conditions.
Another downside is that STP brokers typically offer fewer trading tools and assets compared to market maker brokers due to their lack of a dealing desk.
Market Maker Brokers
Market maker brokers, alternatively known as 'dealing desk' brokers, execute trades against their internal liquidity pool instead of routing them to external providers. This means that market maker brokers take the opposite side of most retail client trades, acting as the other party in the transaction.
As a result, market maker brokers are always exposed to market risk, and they use various risk management strategies to manage this exposure. In essence, market maker brokers open 'pseudo' or 'fake' positions with their clients, acting as the other side of the trade.
Benefits of Market Maker Brokers
Market maker brokers often provide a plethora of trading tools, educational resources, and fixed spreads to their clients. They also cater to a broader range of traders, including beginners, due to their risk management strategies and educational resources.
Furthermore, market maker brokers can mitigate slippage by internal matching of trades, ensuring the client always gets their requested price. They also offer access to a wider range of trading instruments compared to STP brokers.
Drawbacks of Market Maker Brokers
Perhaps the most significant drawback of market maker brokers is the inherent conflict of interest. This arises because market maker brokers have a vested interest in their clients losing trades, as it allows them to offset their market risk.
Market maker brokers may also employ order manipulation techniques such as 'last look', allowing them to reject profitable trades or adjust the upload and download rates of quotes. Lastly, the lack of transparency in the ECN/STP model can make it difficult for traders to assess the market sentiment and dynamics.
Choosing between STP and market maker brokers ultimately comes down to your trading style, risk tolerance, and personal preferences. As a trader, it's essential to understand these different models to make an informed decision based upon your specific needs and goals. Therefore, always do your research, read the fine print, and consider all aspects before partnering with a broker.