can a handyman replace a toilet

Can Handyman Replace Toilet? DIY Guide

By
AD

Discovering that your toilet needs replacing can be an unwelcome surprise. The typical reaction is to call a professional plumber, but for minor issues or simple swaps, a handy homeowner might wonder, "Can a handyman replace a toilet?" The answer is yes, but it comes with considerations.

Understanding when and how to take on this task is crucial. This guide will walk you through the process, with a focus on when to call a professional. After all, while replacing a toilet isn't brain surgery, it's not an ideal first project for a DIY novice.

Should You Attempt To Replace Your Toilet Yourself?

Before you grab your tool belt, consider your skill level and the job's complexity. Most toilets installed after the 1990s use the same basic dimensions and installation methods, making replacement straightforward for a seasoned DIYer. However, if you're new to plumbing, it's essential to understand what you're getting into.

AD
How To Replace a Toilet Like a Pro (DIY)
How To Replace a Toilet Like a Pro (DIY)
How To Replace A Toilet - Penny Pinchin' Mom
How To Replace A Toilet - Penny Pinchin' Mom
How to replace a toilet wax ring - Handyman Larry
How to replace a toilet wax ring - Handyman Larry

Replacing a toilet involves turning off water lines, removing the old toilet, skirting around the old wax ring, preparing the new toilet, and ensuring a watertight seal. It's not rocket science, but it does require careful execution to prevent leaks and ensure longevity.

Skills You'll Need

To replace a toilet, you'll need basic DIY skills, including the ability to use tools like a wrench, screwdriver, and putty knife. You should also be comfortable with some plumbing knowledge, such as which size bolts and nuts you'll need and how to install a new wax ring.

How to Replace a Toilet Yourself (A Weekend Job)
How to Replace a Toilet Yourself (A Weekend Job)
How to Replace a Toilet (Step-by-Step)
How to Replace a Toilet (Step-by-Step)
How to Remove a Toilet Yourself: Stop Paying for Plumbers!
How to Remove a Toilet Yourself: Stop Paying for Plumbers!

It's also crucial to understand the importance of precise alignment and leveling. A toilet that's not level can cause water to leak and may require frequent flushes, leading to higher water bills and potential damage to your floor.

When To Call A Professional

Even if you're handy, there are situations where it's best to call a professional plumber. For instance, if your toilet is more than 30 years old, it might not conform to standard dimensions or installation methods, making replacement more challenging. Additionally, if your toilet is accompanied by signs of significant water damage or if the floor beneath it is weak or unstable, a professional should handle the job.

AD

Lastly, if your job involves moving plumbing lines or dealing with older pipes, it's typically best to leave it to a pro. Incorrect pipe manipulation can lead to serious water damage, mold, and costly repairs.

Easy Steps for Replacing a Toilet
Easy Steps for Replacing a Toilet
How To Install A Toilet
How To Install A Toilet
How to Stop Your Toilet from Wobbling
How to Stop Your Toilet from Wobbling
Tips on Replacing a Toilet
Tips on Replacing a Toilet
How To Replace a Toilet Fill Valve
How To Replace a Toilet Fill Valve
How to Replace a Toilet Wax Ring
How to Replace a Toilet Wax Ring

Preparing To Replace Your Toilet

Before you dive in, ensure you have the right tools and supplies. You'll need a new toilet, naturally, as well as a new wax ring, bolts, nuts, and washers. You'll also need a wax ring remover tool, a hacksaw or reciprocating saw, a putty knife, a new supply tube, and Teflon tape.

Clear the area around your toilet, and be prepared for a bit of mess. Removing the old toilet can get dirty, so lay down some old towels or sheets to protect your floor.

AD

Turn Off The Water Supply

Before removing the old toilet, turn off the water supply valve located behind the toilet. Flush to clear the tank, then turn off the water at the shutoff valve. If the valve leaks or won't turn, you may need to shut off the main water supply.

How to Replace a Toilet Seat
How to Replace a Toilet Seat
Easy Steps for Removing a Toilet
Easy Steps for Removing a Toilet
Toilet Repairs - Part 2 - Replacing the Fill Valve
Toilet Repairs - Part 2 - Replacing the Fill Valve
How to Replace, Repair & Re-attach Your Toilet
How to Replace, Repair & Re-attach Your Toilet
How to Replace a Toilet - Fine Homebuilding
How to Replace a Toilet - Fine Homebuilding
How to Replace a Toilet | Easy DIY Bathroom Project
How to Replace a Toilet | Easy DIY Bathroom Project
Replacing A Toilet Is Easy And Quick, Check Out Our Step By Step Tutorial
Replacing A Toilet Is Easy And Quick, Check Out Our Step By Step Tutorial
How to Replace a Broken Toilet Flush Lever
How to Replace a Broken Toilet Flush Lever
DIY Toilet Repair: 5 Common Commode Problems and How to Fix Them
DIY Toilet Repair: 5 Common Commode Problems and How to Fix Them
How to Remove and Replace a Toilet – A Complete Guide
How to Remove and Replace a Toilet – A Complete Guide
HOW TO REPLACE A TOILET TANK LEVER
HOW TO REPLACE A TOILET TANK LEVER
How to Install Toilet Handle: Ultimate Guide (2025)
How to Install Toilet Handle: Ultimate Guide (2025)

Depressurize the system by letting the tank empty and then opening the supply line. If there's no water pressure, it's safe to continue.

Remove The Old Toilet

Disconnect the water supply line from the tank. Unscrew the bolts secure the toilet to the floor. Carefully lift the toilet off the floor, keeping it level to avoid damaging the plumbing hooks. A toilet lift might be helpful here.

AD

Use a putty knife or scraper to pry up the old wax ring and the caulk around the base. If the old bolts and nuts are salvageable, remove them. Otherwise, they'll need to be left in place.

Prepare The New Toilet

First, ensure your new toilet is exactly the same size and shape as your old one. For a no-hassle swap, buy the same make and model if you can. Fit the bolts, nuts, and washers onto the new toilet.

Apply a manufacturer-approved sealant around the base of your new toilet. Position the new wax ring onto the waste outlet, and align the toilet over the bolt holes. Gently lower the toilet onto the floor, and secure it with the bolts.

Connect The Water Supply

Attach a new supply tube to the new toilet's inlet and the shutoff valve. Tighten the connection with your hands, then secure it with a wrench. Wrap the connection with Teflon tape to prevent leaks.

Turn on the water supply valve slowly, and check for leaks. Flush the toilet several times to ensure it works correctly.

Congratulations, you've successfully replaced your toilet! Regular maintenance, including cleaning and a visual inspection, can keep your new toilet functioning well for years to come. However, if you ever feel in over your head or encounter a persistent problem, don't hesitate to call a professional plumber.

AD