do insurance companies have to match siding

Insurance Siding Match Requirements: Do They Have To?

By
AD

When considering home insurance, one of the most common questions homeowners ask is, "Do insurance companies match siding when they replace it due to damage?" The answer to this question isn't a simple yes or no, as it depends on various factors, including your specific policy, the extent of damage, and the type of siding. Let's delve into these aspects to provide a comprehensive understanding of this topic.

Homeowners insurance typically covers siding damage caused by events listed in your policy, such as fire, windstorms, or vandalism. However, the level of coverage and whether they match the siding can vary significantly. Your policy's coverage section and exclusions will outline what's covered and what's not regarding siding.

Understanding Your Policy

Before discussing siding matching, it's crucial to comprehend your policy's coverage for siding.

AD
Do Insurance Companies Have to Match Shingles After Damage?
Do Insurance Companies Have to Match Shingles After Damage?
𝐂𝐨𝐬𝐭 π‚π¨π¦π©πšπ«π’π¬π¨π§ πŸ• 𝐒𝐒𝐝𝐒𝐧𝐠 π“π²π©πžπ¬
𝐂𝐨𝐬𝐭 π‚π¨π¦π©πšπ«π’π¬π¨π§ πŸ• 𝐒𝐒𝐝𝐒𝐧𝐠 π“π²π©πžπ¬
Build Equity With New Siding
Build Equity With New Siding

Named Perils vs. Open Perils

Named perils policies list specific events that are covered. If the siding damage is caused by an event not listed, you won't be covered. Open perils policies, on the other hand, cover all events except those explicitly excluded. Most homeowners insurance policies nowadays are open peril.

Ensure you know whether your policy is a named perils or open perils, and familiarize yourself with the list of covered or excluded events to understand the scope of siding damage protection.

a man standing in front of a house pointing at something on the wall with his hand
a man standing in front of a house pointing at something on the wall with his hand
EIFS vs Fiber Cement vs Vinyl Siding
EIFS vs Fiber Cement vs Vinyl Siding
Idealproject
Idealproject

Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value

Your policy will also specify whether you're covered for replacement cost or actual cash value (ACV). Replacement cost pays for the full cost of replacing your siding without deducting for depreciation, while ACV deducts depreciation from the settlement.

Older siding, for instance, might not be entirely depreciated, leading to a lower payout if your policy has ACV. It's generally better to have replacement cost coverage, as it ensures your siding will be fully replaced without financial loss due to depreciation.

AD

Siding Matching: Does Your Insurer Have to Match?

Once you've understood your policy's coverage for siding, the next question is: Does the insurance company have to match your existing siding?

3 Industry Secrets that Influence the Cost of Vinyl Siding
3 Industry Secrets that Influence the Cost of Vinyl Siding
a man and woman standing next to a house that is being torn down by the wind
a man and woman standing next to a house that is being torn down by the wind
Fresh Curb Style With exterior house siding
Fresh Curb Style With exterior house siding
Understand the 6 basic coverages.
Understand the 6 basic coverages.
Explore Our Wide Range of Siding Options
Explore Our Wide Range of Siding Options
Siding Cost: Top 10 Reasons Behind It
Siding Cost: Top 10 Reasons Behind It

Matching siding is not legally required. Insurance companies are obligated to restore your home to its pre-loss condition, but there are no regulations specifying that they must match the existing siding material precisely.

Material Availability & Age

Insurance companies are not responsible for sourcing specific or discontinued materials to match your existing siding. If your siding is old and the material is no longer available, they'll opt for the nearest match possible or suggest alternative materials.

AD

They might also deny matching siding altogether if the existing siding is beyond its lifespan and updating the entire exterior would be more cost-effective. In such cases, they would settle with a cash payment based on your policy's coverage.

the different types of siding materials
the different types of siding materials
2024 Summer-Season Installation: How Much Should A New Siding Cost?
2024 Summer-Season Installation: How Much Should A New Siding Cost?
Request a Siding Project Quote | James Hardie James Hardie Siding, Hardie Siding, James Hardie, Exterior Siding, Siding, Exterior, Quotes
Request a Siding Project Quote | James Hardie James Hardie Siding, Hardie Siding, James Hardie, Exterior Siding, Siding, Exterior, Quotes
4 Popular Types of Siding for Your Home's Exterior
4 Popular Types of Siding for Your Home's Exterior
15 Secrets About Siding
15 Secrets About Siding
the different colors of vinyl siding
the different colors of vinyl siding
This is how often you should have the exterior of your house cleaned to maintain your property value and avoid costly siding repairs
This is how often you should have the exterior of your house cleaned to maintain your property value and avoid costly siding repairs
When your vinyl siding needs to be replaced?
When your vinyl siding needs to be replaced?
The right siding matters
The right siding matters
How to Choose the Right Siding for Your House - Fine Homebuilding
How to Choose the Right Siding for Your House - Fine Homebuilding
Professional Siding Services | Protect & Beautify Your Home
Professional Siding Services | Protect & Beautify Your Home
Home Siding Infographic: Siding Comparison β€” Home Remodeling and Home Improvement
Home Siding Infographic: Siding Comparison β€” Home Remodeling and Home Improvement
a gray house with a white pipe on the side and a brown potted plant next to it
a gray house with a white pipe on the side and a brown potted plant next to it
How To Evaluate Contractors’ Siding Quotes
How To Evaluate Contractors’ Siding Quotes

Improvement & Betterment

Some policies include betterment clauses, which allow insurers to deduct depreciation for the portion of the siding being replaced. This deduction is made under the assumption that improving part of the siding enhances the value of the entire structure. A betterment clause might reduce your payout if your siding was approaching its lifespan or had significant wear and tear.

Conversely, some policies offer adjustment for improvement, increasing your settlement to account for the enhanced value of your home due to the updated siding.

AD

Given these factors, it's essential to review your policy carefully and communicate openly with your insurance adjuster about your expectations and concerns. Negotiating the fine print of your policy and understanding its implications can help you make informed decisions about your siding replacement.

Lastly, it's imperative to document the condition of your siding and home before filing a claim. Taking photos or videos of visible wear and tear, along with keeping records of any past repairs or maintenance, can help support your claim and ensure a smooth settling process.

In an ideal world, your insurance company would match your siding to maintain the aesthetic integrity of your home. However, understanding their limitations, policy terms, and the legal aspects of siding replacement better equips you to navigate the claims process and make decisions that benefit your home and your wallet. Stay knowledgeable, and remember to review and update your policy regularly to ensure it addresses your evolving needs and expectations.

AD