is it cheaper to make your own ranch dressing

DIY Ranch Dressing: Is Homemade Cheaper?

By
AD

Ever wondered if whipping up your own ranch dressing at home would actually save you money in the long run? While it might seem cheaper to just pick up a bottle from the store, let's dive into the costs, benefits, and considerations of making your own. Grab a bowl and let's get mixing.

The stereotypical argument for making your own dressings is that store-bought ones are filled with high fructose corn syrup, artificial preservatives, and other culprits you'd rather avoid. But does the DIY approach truly save you money? Let's find out.

Grocery List and Cost Analysis

First, let's examine the ingredients required to make a batch of homemade ranch dressing. We'll compare it with the cost of buying a bottle from the store. Prices may vary depending on the store and brand, but this should give you a general idea.

AD
Best Ranch Dressing Recipe
Best Ranch Dressing Recipe
Homemade Ranch Dressing Recipe – Tasty Salad Dressing Recipes
Homemade Ranch Dressing Recipe – Tasty Salad Dressing Recipes
How To Thin Out Ranch Dressing [Store Bought Or Homemade]
How To Thin Out Ranch Dressing [Store Bought Or Homemade]

Here's a simple homemade ranch recipe: mayonnaise, sour cream, buttermilk, milk, dried parsley, dried dill, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and pepper. Now, let's break down the costs.

Mayonnaise and Sour Cream

Mayo and sour cream are usually the most expensive components. A 30-ounce jar of mayo costs around $3, and a 16-ounce carton of sour cream is about $2.50. Together, that's $5.50. A 16-ounce bottle of store-bought ranch is typically around $2 to $3.

the best ever homemade ranch dressing mix in a jar with spoons next to it
the best ever homemade ranch dressing mix in a jar with spoons next to it
HOMEMADE RANCH DRESSING
HOMEMADE RANCH DRESSING
healthy homemade ranch dressing with cucumber, carrots and crackers on the side
healthy homemade ranch dressing with cucumber, carrots and crackers on the side

However, homemade dressing uses only a fraction of these ingredients for a single batch, so the jars last for multiple batches. Assuming you'll use about a cup of mayo and half a cup of sour cream per batch, you'll get around five batches from each jar, totaling about $1.10 per batch for these two ingredients alone.

Other Ingredients

Dried herbs, spices, and liquids make up the rest of the recipe. These items last much longer and are generally much cheaper. For example, a $1.50 spice packet containing dried parsley, dill, garlic powder, and onion powder can make numerous batches. When it comes to buttermilk and milk, using only a cup or two per batch, you'll get several batches from each gallon.

AD

Adding these costs together, a rough estimate for a batch of homemade ranch might look something like this:

Best Restaurant-Style Ranch Dressing Recipe (Creamy & Flavor-Packed)
Best Restaurant-Style Ranch Dressing Recipe (Creamy & Flavor-Packed)
How To Make Cheddars Ranch Dressing
How To Make Cheddars Ranch Dressing
Easy Homemade Ranch Dressing
Easy Homemade Ranch Dressing
Wingstop Ranch Dressing Copycat for Parties
Wingstop Ranch Dressing Copycat for Parties
the best ranch you'll ever make is in a mason jar with carrots next to it
the best ranch you'll ever make is in a mason jar with carrots next to it
Outback Ranch Dressing (Copycat Recipe)
Outback Ranch Dressing (Copycat Recipe)
IngredientCost per Batch
Mayo & Sour Cream$1.10
Spices & Herbs$0.50
Buttermilk & Milk,$0.40
Total$1.90

Compare that to the $2 to $3 for a store-bought bottle, and it seems like making your own is cheaper – but is it?

Batch Size and Consumption

Homemade ranch keeps best when used within a week. If you're a light user, that might mean half a batch goesbad before you finish it. That makes the cost-per-use higher than buying a bottle that will last much longer.

AD

On the other hand, if you're a heavy user, you might go through multiple batches quickly, making the homemade option more cost-effective. Moreover, since you control the ingredients, you can adjust the batch size and seasoning to theft tastes.

Copycat Rockola Ranch Dressing Recipe
Copycat Rockola Ranch Dressing Recipe
Texas Roadhouse Ranch Dressing
Texas Roadhouse Ranch Dressing
Easy, Semi-Homemade Ranch Dressing
Easy, Semi-Homemade Ranch Dressing
homemade ranch dressing mix in a mason jar
homemade ranch dressing mix in a mason jar
Easy Homemade Buttermilk Ranch Recipe
Easy Homemade Buttermilk Ranch Recipe
Texas Roadhouse Ranch Dressing Copycat Recipe
Texas Roadhouse Ranch Dressing Copycat Recipe
Simple Ranch (Regular Milk, not Buttermilk)
Simple Ranch (Regular Milk, not Buttermilk)
Easy Homemade Ranch Dressing Mix for Salad or Dip on $5 Dinners
Easy Homemade Ranch Dressing Mix for Salad or Dip on $5 Dinners
The Best Homemade Ranch Dressing Recipe (5 Minutes, No Mayo) - An Oregon Cottage
The Best Homemade Ranch Dressing Recipe (5 Minutes, No Mayo) - An Oregon Cottage
how to make ranch dressing without buttermilk in a mason jar on a plate
how to make ranch dressing without buttermilk in a mason jar on a plate
I Taste-Tested The Most Popular Brands Of Ranch, And I Can't Believe How Long I've Missed Out On The Winner
I Taste-Tested The Most Popular Brands Of Ranch, And I Can't Believe How Long I've Missed Out On The Winner
a woman in glasses is holding a bowl filled with liquid and the words restaurant style ranch
a woman in glasses is holding a bowl filled with liquid and the words restaurant style ranch
Say Goodbye to Store-Bought: Best Homemade Ranch Dressing
Say Goodbye to Store-Bought: Best Homemade Ranch Dressing
Ranch Dressing
Ranch Dressing

Customization

A significant advantage of making your own dressings is the opportunity to customize them. Never liked the texture or flavor of store-bought ranch? Make it thicker, thinner, spicier, sweeter, or with any other tweaks you prefer. Plus, you can cater to dietary restrictions – go dairy-free by replacing milk and sour cream with coconut milk and Greek yogurt, for instance.

Batch cooking and freezing for later use could save time and money in the long run. Simply portion out the dressing into individual containers and freeze. Thaw overnight in the fridge when needed. It's a great way to have fresh, homemade dressing on hand without wasting any.

AD

In the end, whether making your own ranch dressing is cheaper depends heavily on your individual usage habits. If you're a frequent user who likes to control what goes into your food, then DIY is likely the more cost-effective option. But if you're a light user, buying store-bought might save you money. Either way, there's no denying the satisfaction of creating your own ranch dressing – it's rewarding, delicious, and made just how you like it.

AD