Postmodern vs Contemporary Dance: A Comparative Analysis
Postmodern dance and contemporary dance, often used interchangeably, are not the same thing. While both emerged in the late 20th century and share some characteristics, they have distinct origins, techniques, and philosophies. Let's delve into the world of these dynamic dance forms to understand their unique identities and commonalities.
The confusion between the two is understandable. Both postpartum and contemporary dance have broken away from traditional ballet and modern dance techniques, emphasizing self-expression, spontaneity, and a departure from classic structures. However, postmodern dance laid the groundwork for contemporary dance, and the latter has since evolved and expanded upon its predecessor's innovations.
Origins and Pioneers
Postmodern dance, born out of the postmodern art movement of the 1960s, was a reaction against the formal structures and aesthetic principles of modern dance pioneers like Martha Graham and Merce Cunningham. Its pioneers, including Lucinda Childs, Trisha Brown, and William Forsythe, advocated for a return to dance's roots - a dance for everyone, not just trained professionals.
Contemporary dance, on the other hand, emerged later, in the 1990s, building on the foundational work of postmodern dance. Its early pioneers encompassed a diverse range of styles and techniques, blending elements from various dance traditions, and further breaking down barriers between choreographer, dancer, and audience.
The Emphasis on Everyday Movement
Both postmodern and contemporary dance share a fascination with everyday movement. Postmodern dance pioneers sought to incorporate everyday gestures and pedestrian movements into their choreography, challenging traditional notions of beauty and grace. Brown's iconic "accumulation" technique, where simple, everyday movements are repeated and built upon, exemplifies this.
Contemporary dance has taken this legacy and run with it. Dancers now draw inspiration from a broader range of sources, including sports, martial arts, and street dance. The movement vocabulary has expanded to include casual, improvisational, and even hyperathletic gestures, reflecting the fast-paced, multimedia-driven world we live in.
Conceptual Frameworks and Societal Commentary
Postmodern dance was deeply invested in theoretical and philosophical discourse. Its practitioners often mined dance history, art theory, and cultural criticism for inspiration, seeking to Intellectually engage their audiences. Concepts like "task-based" choreography, where dances are structured around simple, repeating tasks, became a hallmark of postmodern dance.
Contemporary dance, while maintaining a commitment to intellectual inquiry, has also embraced a raw, emotional authenticity. Today's choreographers are equally likely to draw inspiration from personal experiences, societal issues, or collaborative processes as they are from theoretical frameworks. The result is a dance that is both thought-provoking and deeply moving.
Performance and Choreographic Practices
In terms of performance, both postmodern and contemporary dance are characterized by their informality. Performances often take place in unconventional spaces, like galleries, museums, or even city streets. The relationship between dancer and audience is often less hierarchal, with dancers breaking the fourth wall and engaging directly with the audience.
However, contemporary dance has also seen a resurgence in more traditional, proscenium performances. Today's choreographers are experimenting with new technologies, incorporating multimedia elements like video and sound installations into their work. This hybrid approach reflects contemporary dance's commitment to exploration and adaptation.
Collaboration and Crossover
Both postmodern and contemporary dance have always emphasized collaboration and a blurring of boundaries between different art forms and disciplines. Many postmodern dance pioneers worked extensively with visual artists, sculptors, and musicians. This collaborative spirit has been carried forward into contemporary dance, where cross-disciplinary collaboration is the norm rather than the exception.
Contemporary dance's embrace of hybridity has also led to a surge in crossover work, with choreographers working across ballet, modern, and street dance traditions. This cross-pollination has enriched the dance landscape, fostering a new generation of choreographers who are fluent in multiple dance languages.
The Body as a Site of Revolution
Both postmodern and contemporary dance have challenged and redefined traditional notions of the dancing body. They have resisted rigid aesthetic standards, celebrating diversity in body types, races, and genders. Postmodern dance's inclusive ethos - anyone could dance, regardless of their level of training - has paved the way for contemporary dance's emphasis on individuality and personal expression.
Today, contemporary dance companies are at the forefront of advocating for a more inclusive dance world. They are actively challenging entrenched power structures, advocating for greater diversity and equity in the dance world, and actively seeking out new voices and perspectives.
As we look ahead, it's clear that the lines between postmodern and contemporary dance will continue to blur. Both forms have left an indelible mark on the dance world, paving the way for a new generation of choreographers and dancers who are pushing the boundaries of what dance can be. So, whether you're a fan of postmodern dance's intellectual rigor or contemporary dance's raw emotional power, there's no denying that these dynamic dance forms are here to stay.