q vs q dot thermodynamics

Q vs Q-Dot Thermodynamics: Which is Right for You?

By
AD

Diving into the riveting world of thermodynamics, we stumble upon a fascinating and often confusing linguistic quirk: 'q' versus 'q•'. Both symbols represent heat, a fundamental concept in thermodynamics, but they serve different purposes, leading to a symphony of confusion among beginners and seasoned professionals alike. Let's shed light on this thermodynamic conundrum and unravel the mystery behind these two heat symbols.

Before we delve into the 'q' versus 'q•' debate, let's ensure we're on the same page about heat. In thermodynamics, heat is energy transferred between two systems or an object and its surroundings due to a temperature difference. Now that we've established our baseline, let's explore the two heat symbols and their unique roles.

'q' in Thermodynamics: A General Perspective

The symbol 'q' is used to represent the heat added (or removed) from a system. It's a general term, meaning it applies to any process, regardless of whether it's reversible or irreversible. Whether you're discussing a fusion reaction, a coffee maker, or a steam engine, 'q' is your all-purpose heat symbol.

AD
thermodynamics written in blue ink on a blackboard with white writing
thermodynamics written in blue ink on a blackboard with white writing
Thermodynamics Basics | Physics Cheatsheet & Formulas
Thermodynamics Basics | Physics Cheatsheet & Formulas
Thermodynamics
Thermodynamics

Imagine 'q' as a versatile, all-weather worker. It doesn't discriminate between processes; it simply tracks the heat entering or leaving a system. For instance, in a car's engine, 'q' could represent the heat transferred as fuel is burned, driving the engine's operation.

Work Done 'q'

In some contexts, 'q' can represent the heat added to a system when work is done on it. This might sound counterintuitive, but it's crucial to remember that work and heat are both forms of energy transfer in thermodynamics. So, when work is done on a system, heat is typically added, and 'q' helps us keep track of this energy transfer.

Laws of Thermodynamics
Laws of Thermodynamics
the first law of thermodynamics is shown in this handout
the first law of thermodynamics is shown in this handout
heat and thermodynamics worksheet with diagrams for students to learn
heat and thermodynamics worksheet with diagrams for students to learn

Consider a simple example: a piston-driven engine. When force is applied to the piston, work is done, and heat is generated due to friction. In this case, 'q' would represent the heat produced during this work.

General Heat Transfer

Beyond work-driven heat, 'q' is used to describe any heat transfer between a system and its surroundings. This could be heat entering or leaving a system, just as long as it's clear which direction the heat is moving. By convention, heat added to a system is represented by a positive value of 'q', while heat removed is negative.

AD

For example, in a heating process, 'q' would be positive, indicating heat is entering the system. Conversely, in a cooling process, 'q' would be negative, showing heat is leaving the system.

Thermodynamics and Equations of State for Matter : From Ideal Gas to Quark-gluon Plasma
Thermodynamics and Equations of State for Matter : From Ideal Gas to Quark-gluon Plasma
thermodynamics worksheet with diagrams and notes for students to use
thermodynamics worksheet with diagrams and notes for students to use
a piece of paper with some writing on it
a piece of paper with some writing on it
Thermodynamic Equilibrium
Thermodynamic Equilibrium
thermodynamics formula sheet
thermodynamics formula sheet
Real-time monitoring of CdTe quantum dots growth in aqueous solution - Scientific Reports
Real-time monitoring of CdTe quantum dots growth in aqueous solution - Scientific Reports

'q•' in Thermodynamics: A Reversible Process

Entering the stage like a well-dressed, eloquent gentleman, 'q•' is a more selective heat symbol. It represents heat added (or removed) during a reversible process. Reversible processes are those that can be undone by simply reversing the direction of the heat input or output, without any net change in the system or surroundings.

Think of 'q•' as a refined, discerning worker. It only tracks heat in reversible processes, making it a specialized tool for specific scenarios, such as cyclic or quasistatic processes.

AD

Reversible Heat Transfer

'q•' represents the heat transferred in an infinitesimal reversible process. To grasp this, imagine a 'q•' process so slow that at no point does the system deviate from equilibrium. The heat—and thus, 'q•'—would be transferred in tiny, infinitesimal steps.

thermodynamics worksheet with answers and examples for each student
thermodynamics worksheet with answers and examples for each student
thermo dynamics for heat pump refrigerator with diagrams on it
thermo dynamics for heat pump refrigerator with diagrams on it
thermodynamics important formulas and their functions in physics, including
thermodynamics important formulas and their functions in physics, including
Thermodynamics Basics Formulas | Temperature Conversion & Thermal Expansion
Thermodynamics Basics Formulas | Temperature Conversion & Thermal Expansion
Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics: Why Thermometers Work
Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics: Why Thermometers Work
thermodynamics worksheet is shown with diagrams and graphs on it
thermodynamics worksheet is shown with diagrams and graphs on it
Thermodynamic process quick review
Thermodynamic process quick review
Quantum Correlations Reverse Thermodynamic Arrow of Time | Quanta Magazine
Quantum Correlations Reverse Thermodynamic Arrow of Time | Quanta Magazine
Thermodynamics Formula Sheet | Complete Revision Notes for JEE, NEET & Boards
Thermodynamics Formula Sheet | Complete Revision Notes for JEE, NEET & Boards
Van der Waals & Equipartition Theorem Proving the Adiabatic Relation | Advanced Physics Notes
Van der Waals & Equipartition Theorem Proving the Adiabatic Relation | Advanced Physics Notes
Atoms and molecules in cavities, from weak to strong coupling in quantum-electrodynamics (QED) chemistry | PNAS
Atoms and molecules in cavities, from weak to strong coupling in quantum-electrodynamics (QED) chemistry | PNAS
THERMODYNAMICS ⚡ (1 PAGE REVISION)
THERMODYNAMICS ⚡ (1 PAGE REVISION)
the first law of thermodymaticss is shown in this screenshot
the first law of thermodymaticss is shown in this screenshot
thermodynaics worksheet with answers and examples
thermodynaics worksheet with answers and examples

For instance, consider a gas expanding or contracting slowly and smoothly inside a reversible heat engine. The heat entering or leaving the gas during this process would be represented by 'q•'.

CLAUSES theorem and 'q•'

The Clasius-Clapeyron, Latimer, and van 't Hoff equations, collectively known as the CLAUSES theorem, provide expressions relating the standard Gibbs free energy change, entropy change, and enthalpy change for a reversible reaction. In these equations, 'q•' is often seen, representing the heat added or removed during the reversible reaction.

AD

For example, in the Clasius-Clapeyron equation, 'q•' represents the heat of reaction (ΔH) for a reversible process. This helps us understand and predict the behavior of reversible reactions across different temperatures.

With our exploration complete, we find ourselves at a crossroads. Should we use 'q' or 'q•' to represent heat? The answer isn't always clear-cut, but understanding the distinction helps us communicate more effectively in the dynamic field of thermodynamics. Engage, experiment, and explore—after all, the world of thermodynamics is your laboratory, and the heat symbols are merely your tools.

AD