wirecutter best fireproof safe

Wirecutter's Top Rated Fireproof Safes: Reviews & Picks [2023]

By
AD

In the market for a reliable fireproof safe to protect your valuables? The Wirecutter, a highly reputable product review site, has done the heavy lifting for you. After rigorous testing and comparisons, they've singled out the Honeywell 2602 as their top pick for a fireproof safe. But how does it fare against other competitors, and what factors should you consider before making a purchase?

First and foremost, safeguarding important documents, valuable jewelry, and irreplaceable mementos is a top priority for many homeowners. While ordinary safes offer robust security features, they often fall short when it comes to fire protection. This is where fireproof safes come into play, providing an extra layer of defense againstirebase hazards, ensuring that your precious items can withstand intense temperatures and prolonged heat exposure.

Fireproofing Standards and Ratings

Before diving into the nitty-gritty of the Wirecutter's top picks, let's familiarize ourselves with the crucial aspects of fireproof safes. Understanding their fireproofing standards and ratings is essential for making an informed decision when shopping for a safe.

AD
Take Care of Your Future Self. Get a Fireproof Safe.
Take Care of Your Future Self. Get a Fireproof Safe.
Take Care of Your Future Self. Get a Fireproof Safe.
Take Care of Your Future Self. Get a Fireproof Safe.
Editor's Picks: 8 of Our Favorite Fireproof Safes
Editor's Picks: 8 of Our Favorite Fireproof Safes

Fireproof safes are typically rated by their ability to maintain internal temperatures below a certain degree for a specified period. The most common rating is Underwriters Laboratories (UL)Temperature and Fire Endurance Test, which evaluates a safe's performance through a two-hour fire exposure at 1700°F (927°C). A safe with a UL 1784 rating can preserve the contents inside, keeping the internal temperature below 350°F (177°C) throughout the test.

UL 1784 vs. Underwriters Laboratories Ratings

While the UL 1784 rating is the most recognized and stringent, some safes may also be certified by other organizations, such as Underwriters Laboratories (UL), for additional fire resistance. These safes can provide even more robust protection, extending the duration of fire exposure up to four hours while maintaining the same internal temperature limitations.

SentrySafe 1.2 cu. ft. Fireproof & Waterproof Safe with Digital Combination Lock SFW123GTC - The Home Depot
SentrySafe 1.2 cu. ft. Fireproof & Waterproof Safe with Digital Combination Lock SFW123GTC - The Home Depot
The Best Fire Safes
The Best Fire Safes
a large black box with gold handles and latches on the lid is shown in front of a white background
a large black box with gold handles and latches on the lid is shown in front of a white background

When comparing different fireproof safes, be sure to consider both their UL 1784 and UL ratings to better understand their fire resistance capabilities and make an educated choice based on your specific needs.

Size and Capacity Considerations

Size and capacity are crucial factors to consider when selecting a fireproof safe, as they directly impact the amount and type of items you can store securely. Fireproof safes come in various sizes, from compact, portable models suitable for small items like jewelry and documents to large, heavy-duty safes capable of housing gun collections, cash, and other bulkier valuables.

AD

Always evaluate your storage requirements carefully and opt for a safe that offers adequate interior space without compromising its fireproofing capabilities or portability. Keep in mind that a larger safe may not only accommodate more items but also provide better protection due to its superior insulation and thicker walls.

The Best Fireproof Safes of 2025
The Best Fireproof Safes of 2025
10 Best Fireproof Safes in 2020 [Buying Guide] – Gear Hungry
10 Best Fireproof Safes in 2020 [Buying Guide] – Gear Hungry
The 6 Best Fireproof Safes of 2025, Tested and Reviewed
The 6 Best Fireproof Safes of 2025, Tested and Reviewed
2.0 cu ft Black Digital Premium Fireproof Floor Safe 2-Hour Fire Protection
2.0 cu ft Black Digital Premium Fireproof Floor Safe 2-Hour Fire Protection
Home Fire Proof Safes: Why Have Them & What to Put In Them
Home Fire Proof Safes: Why Have Them & What to Put In Them
The Best Fireproof Safes for Home Use
The Best Fireproof Safes for Home Use

Top Fireproof Safes: Wirecutter Recommendations

Now that you're well-versed in the essential aspects of fireproof safes, let's explore the Wirecutter's top recommendations, each showcasing unique features tailored to different user needs and preferences.

After extensive evaluations and real-world testing, The Wirecutter has crowned the Honeywell 2602 as the best fireproof safe for most people. Boasting a UL 1784 rating and a substantial interior capacity, it offers an outstanding balance between fire protection, security, and affordability. Moreover, its compact size makes it an excellent choice for smaller homes or apartments with limited space.

AD

Honeywell 2602: The Wirecutter's Top Pick

The Honeywell 2602 is a well-rounded safe that excels in numerous aspects, including its rigorous fireproofing capabilities, robust construction, and user-friendly features. Its four live-locking bolts and solid steel body ensure exceptional security, while the pre-attached bolt-down kit allows for easy and secure installation.

a large black tool box on a white background
a large black tool box on a white background
The 6 Best Fireproof Safes of 2025 Fireproof Trunk, Best Safes For Valuable Documents, Black Fireproof Safe, Fire Proof Safe Boxes, Fire-resistant Safe For Home, Wall Safe Fireproof, 5.7 Cu Ft Safe, Fortress Depository Safe, Secure Safe With Anti-theft Features
The 6 Best Fireproof Safes of 2025 Fireproof Trunk, Best Safes For Valuable Documents, Black Fireproof Safe, Fire Proof Safe Boxes, Fire-resistant Safe For Home, Wall Safe Fireproof, 5.7 Cu Ft Safe, Fortress Depository Safe, Secure Safe With Anti-theft Features
The 5 Best Fireproof Safes of 2026, According to Testing
The 5 Best Fireproof Safes of 2026, According to Testing
2.0 cu. ft. Fireproof and Waterproof Safe with Touchscreen Combination Lock
2.0 cu. ft. Fireproof and Waterproof Safe with Touchscreen Combination Lock
12 Best Fireproof Document Safes (July 2026) Tested & Ranked - VVN News
12 Best Fireproof Document Safes (July 2026) Tested & Ranked - VVN News
the first alert box is open and ready to be used as a security device for people with special needs
the first alert box is open and ready to be used as a security device for people with special needs
an open fire door with the words 15 important items worth storing in a fireproof safe
an open fire door with the words 15 important items worth storing in a fireproof safe
6.0 Cuft Extra Large Home Safe Box Fireproof Waterproof, Fingerprint Safe, Home Security Safes Box with Adjustable Shelf & Deposit Slot, Money Safes with Backlit Keypad & Dual Alarm for Home Office, 6.0 Cuft Fingerprint Safe
6.0 Cuft Extra Large Home Safe Box Fireproof Waterproof, Fingerprint Safe, Home Security Safes Box with Adjustable Shelf & Deposit Slot, Money Safes with Backlit Keypad & Dual Alarm for Home Office, 6.0 Cuft Fingerprint Safe
[2026 Upgraded] -35 Min Real Fireproof Safe-3.6 Cu Ft Large Safe For Home Use, S
[2026 Upgraded] -35 Min Real Fireproof Safe-3.6 Cu Ft Large Safe For Home Use, S
MAXSafes 2.6 cu. ft. Fireproof and Waterproof Home, Commercial, and Office Safe with Electronic Keypad Lock Access in White 80007-26 - The Home Depot
MAXSafes 2.6 cu. ft. Fireproof and Waterproof Home, Commercial, and Office Safe with Electronic Keypad Lock Access in White 80007-26 - The Home Depot
What should I keep in my fire safe box? - Your Modern Family
What should I keep in my fire safe box? - Your Modern Family
Kavey 6.0 Cu Ft Extra Large Fireproof Home Safe with Deposit Slot & Digital Keypad - $126.35
Kavey 6.0 Cu Ft Extra Large Fireproof Home Safe with Deposit Slot & Digital Keypad - $126.35
the best fireproof document safe review by wirecutter - product description and price guide
the best fireproof document safe review by wirecutter - product description and price guide
SentrySafe 1.2 cu. ft. Fireproof & Waterproof Safe with Dial Combination Lock SFW123CSBLK - The Home Depot
SentrySafe 1.2 cu. ft. Fireproof & Waterproof Safe with Dial Combination Lock SFW123CSBLK - The Home Depot

Measuring 17.3 x 15.1 x 18.3 inches and weighing nearly 90 pounds, the Honeywell 2602 provides ample storage space for essential documents, valuables, and small firearms. Its fireproofing performance is backed by a one-hour UL 1784 rating, ensuring that your belongings remain safe even in severe fire conditions. As an added bonus, the safe comes with a code key lock with a backup key for quick and convenient access.

Alternative options: Süken and FireKing

If the Honeywell 2602 doesn't quite meet your needs, The Wirecutter has also highlighted two alternative fireproof safes worthy of consideration: the Süken 160 and the FireKing 2436.

AD

The Süken 160 is an excellent choice for those prioritizing portability and compactness, as it offers a balanced combination of fire resistance, security, and space efficiency. Although it's smaller than the Honeywell 2602, the Süken 160 packs impressive fireproofing capabilities with its one-hour UL 1784 rating. Its lightweight design and built-in handle make it easy to transport, while the solid steel construction and pry-resistant door ensure top-notch security.

The FireKing 2436, on the other hand, is ideal for those seeking a hefty, dependable safe that can withstand prolonged fire exposure and accommodate larger, more valuable items. With a UL 1784 rating and an additional four-hour UL rating for added fire resistance, the FireKing 2436 is designed to keep your belongings protected in the most extreme conditions. Its weighty construction and robust security features, including a combination lock and eight locking bolts, make it an excellent choice for gun owners, businesses, or individuals with high-valued collections.

While the Wirecutter's top picks cater to a wide range of user needs, it's essential to assess your specific requirements and priorities before investing in a fireproof safe. By understanding the critical aspects of fireproofing standards, ratings, and careful consideration of size and capacity, you'll be well on your way to selecting the ideal safe for securing your precious belongings.

AD