Worst Modern Main Battle Tanks
A main battle tank (MBT) is a critical component of modern armed forces, designed to be at the forefront of any ground offensive. However, not all MBTs are created equal, and some have stood out for all the wrong reasons due to their poor design, reliability issues, or inadequate performance in combat. Let's delve into the most notorious MBTs that have earned their place among the worst modern battle tanks.
These tanks may have started with promising concepts, but a combination of politics, resource constraints, or technological limitations led to subpar results that sometimes even surpassed expectations in their lackluster performance.
Soviet/Russian Schwerer Panzerkampfwagen T-14 Armata
The T-14 Armata was intended to be the state-of-the-art MBT for the Russian Army, featuring an unmanned turret and advanced composite armor. However, it has faced numerous setbacks and criticisms since its inception.
The T-14's unmanned turret and remote-control system were intended to protect the crew from enemy fire. While innovative, this design has raised concerns about the system's reliability, as well as the lack of immediate crew control over the main armament. Furthermore, the use of an electric drive for the running gear instead of a diesel engine has been criticized for its reduced power and range.
Unreliable Remote-Control System
The T-14's remote-control system has reportedly experienced issues in tests, with some sources claiming that it is prone to malfunctions and can be hacked. Although these allegations remain unsubstantiated, they highlight the potential vulnerabilities of such a complex and innovative design.
Moreover, the system relies on a network of cameras and sensors, which may be vulnerable to interference, damage, or degradation in the heat and dust of battle. This could potentially leave the tank with no immediate fire control, making it vulnerable to enemy attack.
Composite Armor Controversy
The Armata platform's composite armor, known as "Relikt," is believed to provide excellent protection against modern anti-tank weapons. However, thistype of armor is also said to be more prone to damage from internal heat and shock than traditional steel or spaced armor. If true, such weakness could severely impact the T-14's overall durability and effectiveness in combat.
Despite these concerns, Russian officials remain bullish on the T-14's prospects. Only time will tell if the Armata platform can overcome these challenges and earn its place among the world's best MBTs.
American M60 Patton series
The M60 Patton series was developed during the Cold War era to counter the Soviet T-54 and T-62 tanks. While it served the US military well in its early years, the M60 Patton eventually became a poster child for negativity due to various design flaws and shortcomings.
The M60 Patton's main criticism stems from its reliance on a cast upper hull, which makes it susceptible to catastrophic failures under heavy fire or impact. This design has resulted in numerous instances of the M60's hull disintegrating into pieces during combat, leading to significant injuries or even the death of the crew members.
Cast Upper Hull Weakness
The M60 Patton's cast upper hull was originally believed to be stronger than a welded version. However, in practice, it proved to be significantly weaker, as the casting process created stress points and micro-cracks within the metal. These flaws can spread under the stress of combat, ultimately leading to hull failure.
Maintenance crews attempted to address this issue by replacing the cast upper hulls with welded ones, but this costly and time-consuming process has not entirely eliminated the problem. The weak hull design has been a constant source of criticism for the M60 Patton and its derivatives, including the M60A1, M60A2, and M60A3.
Poor Firepower and Protection
While the M60 Patton's 105mm gun was adequate for its time, it soon became evident that it could not compete with the Л110 115mm smoothbore gun found on Soviet T-64 and T-72 tanks. Efforts to rectify this issue led to the development of the M60A1, which mounted a 152mm gun capable of launching anti-tank guided missiles. However, this gun had a limited ammunition supply and required a complex and heavy launch system, which added to the tank's overall weight and complexity.
Moreover, the M60 Patton series was criticized for its inadequate armor protection, which struggled to keep up with advancing armor-piercing ammunition and anti-tank weapons. This ultimately led to the development of the M60A2 and M60A3 variants, which featured improved armor and a more powerful 105mm gun. Nevertheless, these upgrades could not overcome the fundamental weaknesses of the original M60 design.
The M60 Patton series' shortcomings have resulted in its gradual phasing out by the US military in favor of more advanced MBTs like the M1 Abrams. With only a few units remaining in various reserve and training capacities, the M60 Patton series has come to epitomize the flaws that can arise from rushed design and development processes, especially in the face of an ever-evolving threat landscape.Despite the tribulations of these notable MBTs, the pursuit of better tanks continues, driven by advancements in technology and the relentless demands of modern warfare. As we look to the future, akin to refining precious metals from ore, the lessons learned from these worst modern main battle tanks will help inform the development of the next generation of armored vehicles.