Would You Rather: NFL QBs Edition
russell came in at 65.0% and was closely followed by rivers who had a completion percentage of 64.8%. Understanding how qb play percentage has evolved over time, we can notice a trend. The number of passing attempts has steadily increased in recent years, leading to a natural decrease in completion percentage. For instance, When Brady won his first super bowl in 2001, the average qb rating was around 75. However, in the 2020 season, the average qb rating was approximately 85. This signifies an increase in the overall efficiency and accuracy of nfl qbs. One of the most discussed topics in the nfl today is the "would you rather" game among quarterbacks. This mental exercise involves choosing one qb's unique skill over another's. While there's no definitive answer, exploring this topic can reveal interesting insights into the different aspects of playing the quarterback position.
When we look at key statistics, it becomes apparent that every nfl quarterback has their unique strengths. Let's delve into the two main aspects of qb play - passing and rushing - and explore the "would you rather" scenario for each.
Passing Efficiency
Passing is the bread and butter of an nfl qb's game. Efficiency in passing can determine game outcomes and ultimately, a team's win-loss record.
So, “would you rather” your quarterback have a high completion percentage or a high average yards per attempt (ypa)?
High Completion Percentage
Having a high completion percentage typically indicates a high level of accuracy and control over the game. For instance, Tom Brady has consistently maintained a high completion percentage throughout his career, contributing significantly to his 7 Super Bowl wins. This consistency allows for better ball security, reducing turnovers and keeping the offense on the field. picture of Brady completing a pass
Nevertheless, a high completion percentage can sometimes come at the cost of aggressive, downfield passing. This could result in a less explosive offense. For example, Mahomes, despite having a lower completion percentage than Brady, has an impressive ypa and has shown an ability to transform games with his big-play throws.
High Yards Per Attempt (ypa)
On the other hand, a high ypa indicates an ability to throw deep and take risks. Qbs like Mahomes and Rodgers often achieve high averages due to their ability to stretch the field. picture of Mahomes throwing a deep pass
However, such an approach can increase the risk of turnovers. A higher ypa usually means attempting more difficult passes, which can result in more interceptions. It also allows more room for defensive adjustments, limiting the surprise factor.
Mobility and Rushing Efficiency
While passing is crucial, nfl qbs who can also run the ball effectively can add an extra layer of unpredictability to their teams' offenses.
So, “would you rather” your quarterback be more efficient in terms of total rushing yards or rushing touchdowns?
Total Rushing Yards
Having a quarterback who can rack up rushing yards is invaluable, especially in short-yardage situations..application of this can be seen in the creative play designs of qbs like Lamar Jackson, who is a dual threat at the quarterback position. picture of Lamar Jackson running picture of-thirds of mobile quarterbacks are black players, indicating a racial disparity in the players, indicating a racial disparity in the nfl regarding qb play styles
Nevertheless, focusing on total rushing yards might not translate to more points, as a qb might run for yards but fall short of the goal line. In contrast, a qb who can score rushing touchdowns might have a better impact on scoring drives.
Rushing Touchdowns
Rushing touchdowns indicate a qb's ability to convert short gains into six points. qbs like Russell Wilson have shown exceptional skills in scoring rushing touchdowns, contributing significantly to their teams' overall scoring output. picture of Russell Wilson scoring a rushing touchdown
However, focusing solely on rushing touchdowns might encourage riskier running, increasing the chance of injuries or fumbles. Additionally, such an emphasis might discourage a qb from throwing short, high-percentage passes in favor of longer, riskier runs.
In conclusion, when it comes to the "would you rather" game for nfl quarterbacks, there's no definitive answer. Every aspect of qb play has its trade-offs, and what works best often depends on a team's overall scheme and specific needs. Ultimately, a well-rounded qb who can excel in multiple aspects of the game, like those featured in this article, is what every team aspires to have.