cedar city utah murders 1998

Cedar City Utah Murders 1998: A Dark Year in Southern Utah

By
AD

The early morning hours of August 3, 1998, brought shocking news to the quiet town of Cedar City, Utah. Three bodies were found in a home on 300 West, the victims of what would become one of Utah's most notorious and unsolved murder cases. The Cedar City community, known for its close-knit ties and tight-knit groups, was left reeling from the brutal act that claimed the lives of two women and a man.

Andrea maintainer, 42; her daughter, Wanda, 23; and Jimmie-shirtless, 57, were found slain, leaving behind a mystery that has remained unsolved for over two decades. The police were faced with a complex investigation, with the only initial clue being a cryptic note left behind, offering no clear motive or lead to the perpetrators.

The Victims

Andrea Maintainer was a dedicated mother of six, known for her gentle spirit and resilience. After losing her husband in a car accident years prior, she raised her children single-handedly. Wanda, her youngest, was a vibrant and caring individual, studying nursing at nearby Southern Utah University. Jimmy Schrader, a Vietnam veteran, was a well-liked figure in the community, known for his jovial personality and generosity.

AD
a woman with long blonde hair and green shirt smiling at the camera in front of a dark background
a woman with long blonde hair and green shirt smiling at the camera in front of a dark background
Three missing Utah children who vanished two years ago are found ALIVE
Three missing Utah children who vanished two years ago are found ALIVE
Man who killed 3 Utah women said ‘it had to be done’: police
Man who killed 3 Utah women said ‘it had to be done’: police

The two women were found in Andrea's room, their bodies bearing signs of severe trauma, while Jimmy's was discovered in the bathroom. The brutal nature of the crime shocked the town and sparked an immediate investigation by local and federal authorities.

The Investigation

Police arrived at the scene to find the front door locked and no signs of forced entry. inside, they discovered a disheveled room with blood spatter and bloody footprints leading towards the bathroom. Evidence suggested that the victims were attacked in their sleep, and the weapon used was likely a blunt object found at the scene.

Police identify victim in fatal shooting; suspect’s car spotted in Panguitch
Police identify victim in fatal shooting; suspect’s car spotted in Panguitch
Iowa man who killed 3 Utah women said 'it had to be done,' charges say
Iowa man who killed 3 Utah women said 'it had to be done,' charges say
3 women found dead in Utah, including 2 on a hiking trail; suspect in custody
3 women found dead in Utah, including 2 on a hiking trail; suspect in custody

A cryptic note found in the home added to the mystery. It read, "We have something to tell you. We will be back on August 4, 1998." The message's origin and meaning have never been deciphered. Authorities have pursued numerous leads, but none have panned out, leaving the case unsolved to this day.

Theories and Suspects

Over the years, various theories have emerged, ranging from a burglary gone wrong to a crime of passion. Among the suspects is the boyfriend of Wanda at the time, who initially provided investigators with misleading information and had a history of domestic violence. However, he was eventually ruled out due to his military alibi.

AD

Another suspect is a man named James brock, who was arrested in 2010 for the murder of a Utah woman. Despite his similarities to the case's details and the note's mention of a return on August 4, 1998, police never linked him to the Cedar City murders, leaving the possibility of a copycat or unrelated crime.

two police officers standing in front of a house with yellow tape on the ground and trees behind them
two police officers standing in front of a house with yellow tape on the ground and trees behind them
Utah 1959 cold case solved — arrest shocks community
Utah 1959 cold case solved — arrest shocks community
Woman and two men accused in Garden City murder case
Woman and two men accused in Garden City murder case
two pictures of the same woman with blonde hair and orange shirt, one is looking at another
two pictures of the same woman with blonde hair and orange shirt, one is looking at another
an old black and white photo of two people, one with glasses the other without
an old black and white photo of two people, one with glasses the other without
Guns, domestic violence, self-defense tell story of Utah’s 2019 homicides
Guns, domestic violence, self-defense tell story of Utah’s 2019 homicides

The Impact and Legacy

The unsolved murders of Andrea, Wanda, and Jimmy have left profound effects on the Cedar City community. The once-peaceful town has remained vigilant, with residents keeping an eye out for each other and implementing stricter security measures. The Maintainer-Schrader family has faced the unimaginable, finding solace in each other's company but never fully recovering from the tragedy.

The case has also served as a grim reminder of the necessity of thorough criminal investigation and the challenges law enforcement faces in solving complex, cold cases. It has fueled the commitment of detectives and volunteers to keep the case open and active, hoping that one day justice will be served.

AD

The memory of Andrea, Wanda, and Jimmy lives on in the hearts of those who knew them, and the search for their killers continues. As time passes, the need for answers remains as strong as ever, serving as a haunting reminder of the Cedar City murders of 1998 and the unsolved questions that still echo through the quiet streets of this Utah town.

Our latest episode all about the Keddie Cabin Murders. ✔️ it out!
Our latest episode all about the Keddie Cabin Murders. ✔️ it out!
two women and three men standing next to each other in front of a building with police officers behind them
two women and three men standing next to each other in front of a building with police officers behind them
The Hi-Fi Murders
The Hi-Fi Murders
50 More Unbelievable True Crime Murders – Part 3 - Page 2 of 5 - Fact Republic
50 More Unbelievable True Crime Murders – Part 3 - Page 2 of 5 - Fact Republic
This day in history: The suspect in a brazen shopping mall attack in Utah had a local tie and, eventually, an infamous reputation
This day in history: The suspect in a brazen shopping mall attack in Utah had a local tie and, eventually, an infamous reputation
The Search for a Missing Anchorwoman
The Search for a Missing Anchorwoman
1984 Cold Case Murder of 12yr Old Girl
1984 Cold Case Murder of 12yr Old Girl
Client Challenge
Client Challenge
the poster for the boston family murders
the poster for the boston family murders
a young boy in a blue jacket posing for a photo with his hands on his hips
a young boy in a blue jacket posing for a photo with his hands on his hips
After decades, grand jury indicts Galveston County man in notorious ‘Texas Killing Fields’ case | Houston Public Media
After decades, grand jury indicts Galveston County man in notorious ‘Texas Killing Fields’ case | Houston Public Media
AD