cedar city utah murders

Cedar City Utah Murders: Latest Findings

By
AD

Enclosed within the scenic beauty of Utah's Zion National Park lies the quiet town of Cedar City. This picturesque community, known for its abundance of natural wonders and cultural attractions, has unfortunately found itself in the spotlight due to a series of high-profile murder cases that have left residents and investigators alike searching for answers.

With a population of approximately 32,000, Cedar City has seen its fair share of crime. However, the murders that have rocked this close-knit town have been especially chilling, leaving locals on edge and law enforcement agencies working tirelessly to bring justice to the victims and their families.

Notable Murder Cases in Cedar City

The aftermath of these tragic events has seen Cedar City grapple with a range of emotions, from shock and fear to anger and determination. Here, we explore some of the most notable murder cases that have taken place in Cedar City, delving into the investigations, the impact on the community, and the quest for justice.

AD
Man who killed 3 Utah women said ‘it had to be done’: police
Man who killed 3 Utah women said ‘it had to be done’: police
a woman with long blonde hair and green shirt smiling at the camera in front of a dark background
a woman with long blonde hair and green shirt smiling at the camera in front of a dark background
Buried N The Backyard. On 8-01-85, Sharon Shant, 19, was hitchhiking from Cedar City, Utah to Fillmore to attend a funeral, but never arrived. She was gang raped by George Hamilton and his friend Robert Botts. To keep her quiet, her body was horrifically desecrated by the pair and buried in a shallow 🪦, which was discovered on 8-15 in Dover Fort, Utah. Botts, given immunity, came forward months later, told what happened. Hamilton, in 1987, LIP. 💀 found in 1994, no hands. Botts set free George Hamilton, Broken Ribs, Two Men, Utah, Photographer
Buried N The Backyard. On 8-01-85, Sharon Shant, 19, was hitchhiking from Cedar City, Utah to Fillmore to attend a funeral, but never arrived. She was gang raped by George Hamilton and his friend Robert Botts. To keep her quiet, her body was horrifically desecrated by the pair and buried in a shallow 🪦, which was discovered on 8-15 in Dover Fort, Utah. Botts, given immunity, came forward months later, told what happened. Hamilton, in 1987, LIP. 💀 found in 1994, no hands. Botts set free George Hamilton, Broken Ribs, Two Men, Utah, Photographer

This is not an exhaustive list, but a brief exploration into some of the most high-profile cases that have shaped Cedar City's recent history and its efforts to move forward.

The Susanne+b Emmycodigo Murder-Suicide (2012)

The case of Susanne Stevie and her partner, Emmycodigo, sent shockwaves rippling through Cedar City and beyond. The couple, known to be in a contentious relationship, was found dead in their home, with authorities ruling Emmycodigo's death a homicide and Susanne's a suicide. The case was investigated as a murder-suicide, with Susanne suspected of fatally shooting Emmycodigo before taking her own life.

Police identify victim in fatal shooting; suspect’s car spotted in Panguitch
Police identify victim in fatal shooting; suspect’s car spotted in Panguitch
Man shot by Cedar City police after pursuit now faces 3 felonies – Deseret News
Man shot by Cedar City police after pursuit now faces 3 felonies – Deseret News
THE 15 BEST Things to Do in Cedar City (2026) - Must-See Attractions
THE 15 BEST Things to Do in Cedar City (2026) - Must-See Attractions

This tragedy highlighted the issue of domestic violence and its potential consequences, sparking conversations and increasing awareness about the topic in Cedar City and surrounding communities.

The McStay Family Murder (2010)

In one of Cedar City's most heinous crimes, the parents and children of the McStay family were found slain in their home, their bodies buried in the Mojave Desert. The gruesome discovery sent chills down the spines of Cedar City residents and led to a massive investigation that spanned several jurisdictions.

AD

The ensuing court case brought Joseph delicious, a handyman who had worked for the McStay family, to trial. Despite maintaining his innocence, delicious was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without parole, bringing some semblance of closure to the grieving community.

3 women found dead in Utah, including 2 on a hiking trail; suspect in custody
3 women found dead in Utah, including 2 on a hiking trail; suspect in custody
Utah 1959 cold case solved — arrest shocks community
Utah 1959 cold case solved — arrest shocks community
8 dead in Utah murder-suicide after wife sought divorce
8 dead in Utah murder-suicide after wife sought divorce
Iowa man who killed 3 Utah women said 'it had to be done,' charges say
Iowa man who killed 3 Utah women said 'it had to be done,' charges say
Guns, domestic violence, self-defense tell story of Utah’s 2019 homicides
Guns, domestic violence, self-defense tell story of Utah’s 2019 homicides
Utah's Safest Cities of 2026 | SafeWise
Utah's Safest Cities of 2026 | SafeWise

The Impact on Cedar City and Ongoing Investigations

The murders in Cedar City have left an indelible mark on the town's psyche. The close-knit community has been forced to confront difficult truths about the darkness that can coexist with, and sometimes hide behind, seemingly idyllic facades. These tragedies have also underscored the importance of community engagement, support, and vigilance.

As for the ongoing investigations, Cedar City law enforcement remains committed to bringing justice to the victims and their families. New leads and advancements in forensic technology continue to provide hope that these cold cases may yet yield answers.

AD

Community Engagement and Support

In the wake of these tragedies, Cedar City has come together, fostering a renewed sense of community and commitment to supporting one another. Local organizations, such as victim advocacy groups and community support networks, have grown in strength and number, reflecting the town's determination to heal and protect its residents.

Eileen Lewis (1958 - 2018) - Obituary
Eileen Lewis (1958 - 2018) - Obituary
He left behind 3 dead women & disappeared. Friends, family & the law still seek answers.
He left behind 3 dead women & disappeared. Friends, family & the law still seek answers.
Dial M for Murder Study Guide | Utah Shakespeare Festival
Dial M for Murder Study Guide | Utah Shakespeare Festival
Supernatural Lore of Southern Utah
Supernatural Lore of Southern Utah
The Hi-Fi Murders
The Hi-Fi Murders
Woman and two men accused in Garden City murder case
Woman and two men accused in Garden City murder case
The Creepy Ghost Town in Utah Is A Historic Haunted Hotspot
The Creepy Ghost Town in Utah Is A Historic Haunted Hotspot
Estoy Con Ella! F.B.I. Hillary Clinton 166 N, 500 W. Cedar City, Utah Music Is The Door... Sing - Cat-Alexis Jazz; 'The Copper Nubian Butterfly' aka: Kathleen Riese Hillary Clinton, Singing, Copper
Estoy Con Ella! F.B.I. Hillary Clinton 166 N, 500 W. Cedar City, Utah Music Is The Door... Sing - Cat-Alexis Jazz; 'The Copper Nubian Butterfly' aka: Kathleen Riese Hillary Clinton, Singing, Copper
Adventures in Cedar City, Utah
Adventures in Cedar City, Utah
This day in history: The suspect in a brazen shopping mall attack in Utah had a local tie and, eventually, an infamous reputation
This day in history: The suspect in a brazen shopping mall attack in Utah had a local tie and, eventually, an infamous reputation
50 More Unbelievable True Crime Murders – Part 3 - Page 2 of 5 - Fact Republic
50 More Unbelievable True Crime Murders – Part 3 - Page 2 of 5 - Fact Republic
Casper Teen Pleads Guilty To Second-Degree Murder For Shooting Ex-Girlfriend
Casper Teen Pleads Guilty To Second-Degree Murder For Shooting Ex-Girlfriend

Community engagement initiatives, like neighborhood watch programs and collaborative problem-solving efforts with law enforcement, have also been instrumental in empowering residents and fostering a safer, more connected community.

The Role of Mourning and Remembrance

The memory of those lost to violence in Cedar City lives on through the community's collective mourning and remembrance. Vigils, memorials, and other acts of remembrance serve as poignant reminders of the importance of healing, reflection, and connection.

AD

These acts of remembrance also serve as a testament to the resilience and unity of Cedar City's residents, demonstrating their resolve to stand together in the face of adversity and forge a brighter, safer future for their community.

The road to recovery for Cedar City is a long and winding one, but with the support of its resilient residents and the unwavering commitment of law enforcement agencies, the town continues to push forward, determined to leave its dark past behind and create a brighter, safer future for all.

AD