cedar shake alternatives

Cedar Shake Alternatives: Eco-Friendly & Durable Roofing Options

By
AD

The charm of cedar shakes has long captivated homeowners, offering a rustic, natural aesthetic to roofs and walls. However, the high maintenance and expense of real cedar have led many to search for cedar shake alternatives that combine affordability, durability, and similar appeal. This guide explores various options, each with its unique benefits and considerations.

Before delving into the alternatives, it's crucial to understand the allure of cedar shakes. Their rich texture, warm hues, and classic look provide an unparalleled rustic charm. Yet, the high cost, susceptibility to rot, insects, and weather damage make cedar shakes a less practical option for some. But worry not; several cedar shake alternatives can replication the rustic aesthetic while addressing these concerns.

Composite Cedar Shake Alternatives

At the forefront of cedar shake alternatives are composite materials, specifically engineered to mimic the look and feel of real wood. These products offer a blend of affordability, durability, and low maintenance.

AD
The Best Cedar Shake Siding Isn't Made of Wood (Why It Matters)
The Best Cedar Shake Siding Isn't Made of Wood (Why It Matters)
Say Goodbye to High Maintenance with Composite Cedar Shake Siding - Home Improvement DIY
Say Goodbye to High Maintenance with Composite Cedar Shake Siding - Home Improvement DIY
Installing Cedar Shakes - Fine Homebuilding
Installing Cedar Shakes - Fine Homebuilding

Composite cedar shakes come in various materials, such as cellular polyurethane, recycled plastic, and virgin plastic. They are designed to resist rot, insects, and UV damage, ensuring longevity. Moreover, they typically come with a warranty covering extended periods, providing peace of mind for homeowners.

Cellular Polyurethane Composite Shakes

Cellular polyurethane is a popular choice for composite cedar shakes due to its lightweight nature and superior insulation properties. These shakes are produced using a patented process that infuses cells of gas into a polyurethane base, creating a robust, honeycomb-like structure.

Adding Texture and Timeless Character with Our Bartile Roof
Adding Texture and Timeless Character with Our Bartile Roof
Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover
Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding

This construction makes cellular polyurethane composite shakes highly resistant to impact, moisture, and extreme temperatures. They also boast a Class A fire resistance rating, further enhancing their safety profile. Despite their durability, these shakes remain lightweight, reducing the strain on your roof's framework.

Recycled Plastic and Virgin Plastic Composite Shakes

Composite cedar shakes crafted from recycled or virgin plastic offer another eco-friendly alternative to real wood. These shakes combine recycled scraps of plastic with virgin materials to create a durable, weather-resistant product.

AD

The manufacturing process involves heating and compressing the plastic, then injecting it into molds shaped like traditional cedar shakes. This results in a product that closely resembles real wood, from its textured surface to its layered appearance. Like cellular polyurethane options, plastic composite shakes require little maintenance and resist weathering, rot, and mold.

an image of wood shingles that are brown in color and dark on the outside
an image of wood shingles that are brown in color and dark on the outside
OUR PASSTHROUGH TRANSFORMATION + CEDAR SHAKE INSTALL | Nadine Stay
OUR PASSTHROUGH TRANSFORMATION + CEDAR SHAKE INSTALL | Nadine Stay
Hidden Costs of Cedar Shake Roofs: What You Need to Know Before Installing
Hidden Costs of Cedar Shake Roofs: What You Need to Know Before Installing
A Complete Breakdown of Faux Cedar Shake Siding
A Complete Breakdown of Faux Cedar Shake Siding
Installing Cedar Shakes
Installing Cedar Shakes
Garden Shed Cedar Shake Install
Garden Shed Cedar Shake Install

Safer, More Durable Wood Alternatives

While composite materials offer numerous advantages, some homeowners prefer the authentic feel and look of real wood. If you share this sentiment, consider the following wood alternatives that deliver increased durability and safety.

These options often undergo treatment or use naturally resistant species to enhance their longevity and resistance to damage.

AD

Western Red Cedar Shakes

While not an alternative to traditional cedar, Western Red Cedar (WRC) shakes deserve mention due to their enhanced durability. Harvested from heartwood, which is more resistant to rot and insects, WRC shakes offer improved longevity compared to other woods.

Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding
Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding
a close up view of a wooden shingled roof
a close up view of a wooden shingled roof
5 Cape Cod Exterior Cedar Shake Sidings for a Timeless Coastal Look
5 Cape Cod Exterior Cedar Shake Sidings for a Timeless Coastal Look
Shake vs. Cedar
Shake vs. Cedar
How To Restore Cedar Shake Siding That Looks Weathered
How To Restore Cedar Shake Siding That Looks Weathered
Vinyl Cedar Shake Siding: 5 Key Issues and a Better Alternative
Vinyl Cedar Shake Siding: 5 Key Issues and a Better Alternative
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
a bird perched on top of a wooden roof
a bird perched on top of a wooden roof
Cedar Shake Style Metal Roofing
Cedar Shake Style Metal Roofing
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roof Tiles| Standard Shadow Line | EcoStar
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roof Tiles| Standard Shadow Line | EcoStar
24 Inch Royal Shingles | Custom Shingles
24 Inch Royal Shingles | Custom Shingles
an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
Cedar Shingles & Shakes – Cedar Country Lumber
Cedar Shingles & Shakes – Cedar Country Lumber
Natural Cedar Shake Siding - Cedar Shake Exterior Ideas 30 Bold Looks With Timeless Charm
Natural Cedar Shake Siding - Cedar Shake Exterior Ideas 30 Bold Looks With Timeless Charm

Furthermore, Western Red Cedar naturally resists decay, insects, and weathering, thanks to its extractives. Despite these benefits, WRC shakes remain more affordable than traditional cedar, making them a practical alternative for discerning homeowners who prefer real wood.

CYPRESS SHAKES

Cypress, a coniferous tree species, offers another durable wood alternative. Its heartwood contains natural preservatives that resist rot, decay, and insect damage, making cypress a popular choice for outdoor applications.

AD

Cypress shakes exhibit a fine, straight grain pattern and a medium to coarse texture. Like cedar, cypress features a warm, inviting hue that darkens with age, adding to its rustic appeal. While pricier than some composite options, cypress shakes provide a quality, authentic wood alternative that withstands the test of time.

When considering cedar shake alternatives, it's essential to weigh the initial cost against the prospective life span, maintenance requirements, and aesthetic appeal of each material. Whether you opt for a composite or wood alternative, you'll find numerous options that replicate the charm of cedar while enhancing your home's durability and curb appeal. Embrace the journey of exploring these alternatives, and discover the perfect fit for your dream home.

AD