best cedar shake alternatives

Best Cedar Shake Alternatives: Eco-Friendly & Low-Maintenance

By
AD

Cedar shake roofs add a rustic charm and natural beauty to any home, but they're not always the best solution due to their high maintenance and short lifespan. If you're looking for a more durable, low-maintenance alternative, you've come to the right place. In this guide, we'll explore the best cedar shake alternatives that combine aesthetics with functionality.

Before diving into the alternatives, let's briefly discuss why you might want to reconsider cedar shakes. Despite their classic appeal, cedar shakes are prone to warping, splitting, and rotting, especially in harsh weather conditions. They also require frequent cleaning and staining to maintain their appearance. That said, let's look at some excellent alternatives that require less upkeep while providing similar curb appeal.

Resistance to Weathering: composites and metal

When choosing a cedar shake alternative, it's crucial to consider materials that can withstand various weather conditions without deteriorating rapidly. Composite and metal roofing materials are excellent choices in this regard.

AD
Installing Cedar Shakes - Fine Homebuilding
Installing Cedar Shakes - Fine Homebuilding
Cedar Siding Exterior Makeover Inspiration - Exterior House Color Schemes & Exterior Design
Cedar Siding Exterior Makeover Inspiration - Exterior House Color Schemes & Exterior Design
Hidden Costs of Cedar Shake Roofs: What You Need to Know Before Installing
Hidden Costs of Cedar Shake Roofs: What You Need to Know Before Installing

Composite roofing, made from a mix of recycled materials and polymers, replicates the woodgrain texture of cedar shakes while offering improved durability. They are resistant to fading, cracking, and insect damage, ensuring they maintain their appearance over time. Moreover, composite roofs often come with Class A fire resistance ratings, providing an added layer of safety.

Composite Roofing: Long-lasting and eco-friendly

Composite roofing shingles can mimic the look of cedar shakes quite convincingly. They are typically made from a mix of recycled materials and polymers, giving them excellent resistance to weathering, insects, and fire. Plus, they are more environmentally friendly than traditional asphalt shingles. Brands like CertainTeed'sընHandyman Town™ and Tamko's.varpmetri{} series offer stunning cedar shake-inspired designs that can mimic the natural appearance of real wood.

an advertisement for a metal shake roofing company with pictures of different types of shingles
an advertisement for a metal shake roofing company with pictures of different types of shingles
Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover
Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover
The Best Cedar Shake Siding Isn't Made of Wood (Why It Matters)
The Best Cedar Shake Siding Isn't Made of Wood (Why It Matters)

One downside of composite roofing is that it's often more expensive than asphalt shingles. However, their longevity and low maintenance requirements can offset the higher upfront cost in the long run. Moreover, some manufacturers offer warranties lasting up to 50 years, providing peace of mind for homeowners.

Metal Roofing: Durable and energy-efficient

Metal roofing, particularly steel and aluminum, is another excellent alternative to cedar shakes. It's incredibly durable, resistant to denting, fire, and harsh weather conditions. With proper installation, a metal roof can last for over 60 years, making it an excellent long-term investment. Additionally, metal roofs are highly reflective, helping improve energy efficiency by reflecting solar heat away from the home during summer months.

AD

Metal roofing can be designed to resemble the appearance of cedar shakes. Standing seam metal roofing in a woodgrain texture can provide the look of real wood without the maintenance. Alternatively, exposed fasteners like attr crude metal shingles can mimic the rustic aesthetic of cedar shakes. Examples include products from Metro© and Classic'metal©.

Installing Cedar Shakes
Installing Cedar Shakes
a close up view of a wooden shingled roof
a close up view of a wooden shingled roof
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding
Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Adding Texture and Timeless Character with Our Bartile Roof
Adding Texture and Timeless Character with Our Bartile Roof

Vintage charm with modern materials: Slate and concrete

If you're after a more upscale look, slate and concrete tile roofing can provide the classic charm of cedar shakes with enhanced durability and lower maintenance.

Both slate and concrete tiles are highly resistant to fire, rot, and insects, ensuring a long lifespan even in harsh climates. They are also more environmentally friendly compared to asphalt shingles, as they contain recycled materials and can be recycled at the end of their lives. Furthermore, they are available in various colors and styles, allowing you to match the aesthetic of your home.

AD

Slate Roofing: Elegant and enduring

Slate roofing, made from natural stone, offers a sophisticated and timeless look that can match or even surpass the elegance of cedar shakes. Slate tiles are incredibly durable, resistant to extreme weather conditions, and maintenance-free. They can last for centuries, making them an ideal choice for homeowners seeking a long-term investment. However, slate roofing is significantly more expensive than other alternatives, and installation requires experienced professionals due to the roof's weight and delicate nature.

Garden Shed Cedar Shake Install
Garden Shed Cedar Shake Install
5 Cape Cod Exterior Cedar Shake Sidings for a Timeless Coastal Look
5 Cape Cod Exterior Cedar Shake Sidings for a Timeless Coastal Look
A Complete Breakdown of Faux Cedar Shake Siding
A Complete Breakdown of Faux Cedar Shake Siding
How To Restore Cedar Shake Siding That Looks Weathered
How To Restore Cedar Shake Siding That Looks Weathered
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roof Tiles| Standard Shadow Line | EcoStar
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roof Tiles| Standard Shadow Line | EcoStar
Shake vs. Cedar
Shake vs. Cedar
an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
EcoStar Seneca Shake
EcoStar Seneca Shake
Cedar Shake Roof Cost 2026 | Is It Worth the Price?
Cedar Shake Roof Cost 2026 | Is It Worth the Price?
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding
shakes and shingles
shakes and shingles
Cedar Shake Siding: A Comprehensive Guide to Options, Costs, and Maintenance - Today's Homeowner
Cedar Shake Siding: A Comprehensive Guide to Options, Costs, and Maintenance - Today's Homeowner
a man is painting the side of a building with shingle siding and window trimming
a man is painting the side of a building with shingle siding and window trimming
Select Shake: Mossy Cedar
Select Shake: Mossy Cedar

For homeowners interested in the appearance of slate but seeking a more affordable option, synthetic slate roofing made from composite materials is an excellent alternative. These tiles replicate the look and texture of natural slate but are lighter, more flexible, and less prone to cracking. Products like CertainTeed's StoneCrest© or Brava's BoldCrest™ series can mimic the aesthetic of natural slate while offering better affordability and easier installation.

Concrete Tiles: Beauty and strength combined

Concrete tiles, often made from a mixture of cement, sand, and water, are another excellent alternative to cedar shakes. High-quality concrete tiles can mimic the texture and appearance of real wood, providing an attractive, rustic look. They are highly resistant to rot, insects, and fire, ensuring a long lifespan. Plus, they are typically more affordable than slate roofing while offering comparable longevity and aesthetics.

AD

Composition- and color options are abundant in concrete tiles, ranging from sencillo styles to more elaborate Mission or Spanish barrel tiles. If you're looking for a more realistic cedar shake appearance, consider tiles with a hand-split or rough-hewn texture, such as those offered by Eagle Roofing Products or Boral's Country Manor tiles.

When choosing the best cedar shake alternative, consider your home's architecture, your budget, and your region's climate. By opting for durable, low-maintenance materials like composite, metal, slate, or concrete tiles, you can enjoy the rustic charm of cedar shakes without the constant upkeep and worries about longevity. Investing in a high-quality roof will not only enhance your home's curb appeal but also increase its value in the long run. Happy roofing!

AD