is board and batten more expensive than metal siding

Board and Batten vs Metal Siding: Cost Comparison

By
AD

Imagine transforming your home's exterior with a fresh, new look. Two popular choices that often crosslink homeowners' radars are board and batten siding and metal siding. Both offer unique aesthetics and functionalities, but the question lingering in many people's minds is: "Is board and batten more expensive than metal siding?" Let's delve into this intriguing comparison.

Before we dive into the cost aspect, let's briefly understand what each siding type brings to the table.

Board and Batten Siding

Originating from classic timber construction techniques, board and batten siding features wide, overlapping boards and narrow battens that cover the joints. It's often associated with farmhouses and rustic styles but can seamlessly blend with modern architectural designs.

AD
30 Board and Batten Siding Ideas
30 Board and Batten Siding Ideas
Board And Batten Siding Exterior Inspo Ideas
Board And Batten Siding Exterior Inspo Ideas
Guide to Board and Batten Siding
Guide to Board and Batten Siding

Board and batten siding is typically made from cedar, pine, or other woods, with composite and vinyl options also available. Its rustic charm and versatility make it a favored choice among homeowners.

Cost of Wood Board and Batten Siding

Wood siding, including board and batten, comes at a premium price due to the material's inherent qualities and the craftsmanship involved. On average, wood board and batten siding can range from $12 to $18 per square foot, installed. This makes it one of the more expensive siding options available.

Board & Batten Siding Ideas
Board & Batten Siding Ideas
a black and white house surrounded by trees with fall foliage in the foreground on a cloudy day
a black and white house surrounded by trees with fall foliage in the foreground on a cloudy day
What is board and batten?
What is board and batten?

However, it's crucial to consider that wood siding lasts longer than many other materials—up to 20 to 40 years with proper maintenance. Additionally, high-quality wood can add significant resale value to your home.

Cost of Composite Board and Batten Siding

Composite board and batten siding is another popular alternative that mimics the look of real wood while providing low-maintenance and high-durability characteristics. Its cost can vary but generally falls between $8 to $15 per square foot, making it less expensive than authentic wood.

AD

Although slightly more affordable, composite siding may not perfectly replicate the natural grain and texture of wood. Yet, it's an excellent choice for those seeking a low-upkeep solution with a wood-like appearance.

7 Chic Board And Batten Exteriors That Prove Modern Farmhouse Is Just The Beginning - Hunker
7 Chic Board And Batten Exteriors That Prove Modern Farmhouse Is Just The Beginning - Hunker
Contemporary Farmhouse Design, Black Exterior Home Style, Curb Appeal Inspiration For Homes, Modern Black Farmhouse With Metal Roof, Modern Farmhouse Renovation Ideas, Batten Board Siding, Board And Batten Siding Black, Board And Batten Siding Transition, Board And Batten Siding With
Contemporary Farmhouse Design, Black Exterior Home Style, Curb Appeal Inspiration For Homes, Modern Black Farmhouse With Metal Roof, Modern Farmhouse Renovation Ideas, Batten Board Siding, Board And Batten Siding Black, Board And Batten Siding Transition, Board And Batten Siding With
a blue house with white trim on the front and side windows is pictured in this image
a blue house with white trim on the front and side windows is pictured in this image
Best 19+ Board and Batten Exterior Ideas You Need to See
Best 19+ Board and Batten Exterior Ideas You Need to See
a small building with a brown door and windows
a small building with a brown door and windows
Choosing The Right Exterior Siding | Southwest Exteriors - San Antonio
Choosing The Right Exterior Siding | Southwest Exteriors - San Antonio

Metal Siding

Metal siding refers to a broad range of products, including steel, aluminum, and vinyl – each offering unique features and price points. It's renowned for its durability, low maintenance, and low cost. Let's explore its pricing.

Metal siding options are vast, catering to different budgets and design preferences. Here's a quick rundown of their average costs per square foot, installed:

AD
  • Vinyl siding: $3 to $8
  • Aluminum siding: $6 to $12
  • Steel siding: $7 to $14

Longevity and Maintenance Costs

Metal siding is exceptionally durable, with vinyl siding lasting up to 25 years and steel or aluminum lasting up to 40 years or more. Moreover, metal siding is resistant to insects, rot, and fire, making it a low-maintenance option that can save you money in the long run.

10 Stunning Board and Batten Exterior Ideas for Your Home
10 Stunning Board and Batten Exterior Ideas for Your Home
24 Board and Batten Siding Colors Fresh Exterior Tone - Too Much Time
24 Board and Batten Siding Colors Fresh Exterior Tone - Too Much Time
a white house with brown shutters on the front and side windows that say board and batten
a white house with brown shutters on the front and side windows that say board and batten
23 Board and Batten House Exterior for Modern Farmhouse Charm That Feels Fresh and Inviting
23 Board and Batten House Exterior for Modern Farmhouse Charm That Feels Fresh and Inviting
LP Smart Siding Board and Batten Siding Ideas - Today's Homeowner
LP Smart Siding Board and Batten Siding Ideas - Today's Homeowner
Board and Batten Siding
Board and Batten Siding
a house with the words board and batten siding from james hardie
a house with the words board and batten siding from james hardie
30 Board and Batten Exterior Ideas for a Stunning Facade - Suite 101
30 Board and Batten Exterior Ideas for a Stunning Facade - Suite 101
Board 'n Batten Brochure
Board 'n Batten Brochure
30 Unique Ways to Incorporate Board and Batten Siding Into Your Design
30 Unique Ways to Incorporate Board and Batten Siding Into Your Design
the home decor guide to board and batten siding diy board is now available
the home decor guide to board and batten siding diy board is now available
Steel Board and Batten Steel Siding
Steel Board and Batten Steel Siding
Exterior Board & Batten Siding Creates Casual Look
Exterior Board & Batten Siding Creates Casual Look

However, metal siding may not hold up as well in extreme temperatures or direct sunlight, potentially leading to warping, fading, or chalking. Furthermore, while vinyl siding is relatively inexpensive, the environmental impact and recyclability of metal siding might be a factor to consider.

Appearance and Curb Appeal

Metal siding comes in various colors and styles, with some designs mimicking the look of wood or other materials. However, it might not capture the natural, organic charm of wood siding, which could impact your home's curb appeal, especially if you're aiming for a rustic or craftsman-style look.

AD

On the other hand, metal siding can be a smart choice for homeowners wanting a low-maintenance option with a clean, modern aesthetic.

In comparing board and batten vs. metal siding, it's evident that metal siding tends to be more budget-friendly, with vinyl siding being the most affordable option. However, if you prioritize the warm, organic look of wood, the durability and longevity of board and batten siding, and aren't averse to some maintenance tasks, investing in wood or composite board and batten siding could be a worthwhile consideration.

Ultimately, the choice between board and batten and metal siding depends on your personal preferences, budget, and long-term plans for your home. Consulting with a professional contractor can shed further light on the ideal choice for your specific needs and help bring your dream exterior to life.

AD