Board & Batten vs Lap Siding: Cost Comparison
Board and batten siding and lap siding are both popular choices for home exteriors, but when it comes to cost, which one reigns supreme? Let's delve into the world of siding materials to find out if board and batten siding is indeed more expensive than its lap siding counterpart.
First, let's define these two siding types. Lap siding, also known as clapboard siding, consists of horizontal planks that overlap each other. Board and batten siding, on the other hand, is composed of wide vertical boards with narrower battens covering the seams.
Material Comparison
Before we compare the costs, let's explore the materials used for each type. Both can be made from a variety of materials, including vinyl, wood, and fiber cement. However, the most common materials for both are vinyl and fiber cement due to their durability and low maintenance requirements.
Vinyl and fiber cement boards for lap siding typically come in standard widths, while board and batten may require custom milling for wider planks, which can slightly elevate its material cost.
Vinyl Siding
Vinyl is generally the most affordable option for both lap and board and batten siding. It's known for its durability, resistance to rot and pests, and low maintenance requirements. However, while vinyl board and batten siding might have slightly higher material costs due to custom milling, the difference is usually minimal.
Cost per square foot (Vinyl): - Lap siding: $2 - $7 - Board and batten siding: $3 - $8 (slightly higher due to custom milling)
Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement is more expensive than vinyl but offers exceptional durability and longevity. It can withstand extreme weather conditions and requires little maintenance. Similar to vinyl, custom milling for board and batten siding can slightly increase its cost, but the difference is not significant.
Cost per square foot (Fiber Cement): - Lap siding: $7 - $14 - Board and batten siding: $8 - $15 (slightly higher due to custom milling)
Labor Costs
Labor costs can vary greatly depending on your location, the existing siding, and the complexity of the installation. Board and batten siding often takes longer to install due to its custom nature, which can increase labor costs.
However, it's essential to note that these costs can vary greatly and are not exclusively tied to the siding type. For instance, if your home has curves or corners, both siding types will likely require additional labor time.
Time and Materials
The cost of time is a crucial factor in labor costs. Generally, board and batten siding takes longer to install due to the custom cuts required and the need for more precise measuring and spacing. This can result in higher labor costs.
However, the difference in labor costs between the two types can vary significantly. While some contractors may charge a premium for board and batten siding, others might not due to their familiarity with the technique.
Is Board and Batten Siding More Expensive?
In conclusion, while board and batten siding may have slightly higher material and labor costs than lap siding, the difference is usually minimal. The primary factor influencing cost is not the siding type but your home's complexity and the local labor market. Moreover, the aesthetic appeal and curb appeal boost that board and batten siding offers can often offset any additional costs.
Ultimately, the best way to determine if board and batten siding is more expensive for your specific situation is to consult with a professional siding contractor. They can provide a tailored estimate based on your home's needs and your local market conditions.