alternatives to cedar shakes

5 Best Alternatives to Cedar Shakes

By
AD

Cedar shakes are a popular choice for roofing and siding due to their durability and aesthetic appeal. However, they're not the only option available. For those looking to explore alternatives, this article presents several viable options that offer a mix of affordability, sustainability, and longevity.

Cedar shakes may offer a classic rustic look, but their maintenance, cost, and environmental impact can be significant drawbacks. Let's delve into some compelling alternatives that can mimic the appearance of cedar shakes while addressing these concerns.

Engineered Wood Shakes

Engineered wood shakes are a strong contender in the world of roofing and siding materials. They're designed to mimic the look of natural cedar shakes but with several advantages.

AD
Cedar Siding Exterior Makeover Inspiration - Exterior House Color Schemes & Exterior Design
Cedar Siding Exterior Makeover Inspiration - Exterior House Color Schemes & Exterior Design
Adding Texture and Timeless Character with Our Bartile Roof
Adding Texture and Timeless Character with Our Bartile Roof
Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover
Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover

Made from a combination of wood and resin, these shakes are more durable and resistant to rot, decay, and insect damage than their natural counterparts. They require less maintenance, have a consistent appearance, and are available in a range of colors to suit different architectural styles.

Composite Shakes

Composite, or synthetic, shakes are another excellent alternative. Manufactured from a blend of plastic and recycled materials, they offer unparalleled durability and low maintenance.

Installing Cedar Shakes - Fine Homebuilding
Installing Cedar Shakes - Fine Homebuilding
Shake vs. Cedar
Shake vs. Cedar
Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding
Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding

Available in a variety of textures and colors, composite shakes can mimic the look of real cedar shakes while being more resistant to weathering, fading, and impacts. They don't absorb moisture, meaning they're less likely to warp, split, or crack over time.

Asphalt Shingles with a Cedar Shake Appearance

Asphalt shingles are a more affordable option that can also mimic the appearance of cedar shakes. Newer shingles in the architectural and premium categories offer a range of profiles, including those that resemble the dimensionality and texture of wood shakes.

AD

These shingles are designed to be durable, with manufacturers offering warranties ranging from 20 to 50 years. They're also lighter than wood shakes, making them a good choice for older homes with structural considerations.

Before You Replace Cedar Shake Siding, Read This
Before You Replace Cedar Shake Siding, Read This
a close up view of a wooden shingled roof
a close up view of a wooden shingled roof
The Best Cedar Shake Siding Isn't Made of Wood (Why It Matters)
The Best Cedar Shake Siding Isn't Made of Wood (Why It Matters)
Garden Shed Cedar Shake Install
Garden Shed Cedar Shake Install
Rusticseries 2025 - Amazing Products
Rusticseries 2025 - Amazing Products
5 Cape Cod Exterior Cedar Shake Sidings for a Timeless Coastal Look
5 Cape Cod Exterior Cedar Shake Sidings for a Timeless Coastal Look

Metal Roofing with a Wood Shake Aesthetic

Metal roofing is known for its durability and longevity, and it can now be designed to resemble cedar wood shakes. High-quality metal roofing can last for 40 to 70 years or more, making it a sound investment.

Available in steel and aluminum, metal roofing with a wood shake appearance can withstand extreme weather conditions, resist fire, and require minimal maintenance. The initial cost is higher than some other options, but the long lifespan can make it a cost-effective choice in the long run.

AD

Standing Seam Metal Roofing

Standing seam metal roofing is another option that can mimic the look of cedar shakes. This type of roofing features vertical panels that are interlocked at the seams, which run horizontally along the roof.

an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
an old brick building with a clock on it's side and a sky background
Hidden Costs of Cedar Shake Roofs: What You Need to Know Before Installing
Hidden Costs of Cedar Shake Roofs: What You Need to Know Before Installing
How We Transformed An Awkward Bedroom Exterior With Cedar Shingle Siding | Nadine Stay
How We Transformed An Awkward Bedroom Exterior With Cedar Shingle Siding | Nadine Stay
The Difference Between Cedar Shingles & Cedar Shakes - Congleton Lumber & Design Center
The Difference Between Cedar Shingles & Cedar Shakes - Congleton Lumber & Design Center
Installing Cedar Shakes
Installing Cedar Shakes
2023 Recap - Mindy Gayer Design Co.
2023 Recap - Mindy Gayer Design Co.
a small building with two lights on each side and a door to the other side
a small building with two lights on each side and a door to the other side
ProVia Timberbay Cedar Shake Siding
ProVia Timberbay Cedar Shake Siding
Better Than Wood: Composite Cedar Shake Roof Tile
Better Than Wood: Composite Cedar Shake Roof Tile
A Complete Breakdown of Faux Cedar Shake Siding
A Complete Breakdown of Faux Cedar Shake Siding
30 Charcoal Grey House Design With Cedar Shake Ideas to Inspire - Lost At E Minor
30 Charcoal Grey House Design With Cedar Shake Ideas to Inspire - Lost At E Minor
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Shingles - Composite Faux Cedar Shakes
Composite Shake Siding that Looks like Cedar - Coventry Log Homes Beach House Shake Exteriors
Composite Shake Siding that Looks like Cedar - Coventry Log Homes Beach House Shake Exteriors

Standing seam metal roofing is known for its durability, energy efficiency, and ability to withstand high winds. It's also suitable for complex roof designs, making it a versatile choice for both residential and commercial buildings.

Metal Roofing Tiles with a Wood Shake Appearance

Metal roofing tiles designed to replicate the appearance of wood shakes are another option to consider. These tiles typically feature a textured surface and raised grains that mimic the look of natural wood.

AD

Metal roofing tiles are lightweight, durable, and resistant to fire, moisture, and pests. They're also available in a variety of colors to suit different architectural styles.

In the market for an alternative to cedar shakes? From engineered wood to metal roofing, there are plenty of options that offer a blend of aesthetics, durability, and sustainability. When choosing the right alternative, consider your budget, local climate, and long-term maintenance requirements. With the right selection, you can enjoy the charm of cedar shakes without the drawbacks. Contact a local roofing professional for guidance tailored to your specific needs.

AD