is vinyl shake siding more expensive

Vinyl Shake Siding Cost: Is it More Expensive?

By
AD

When considering vinyl shake siding for your home, one of the primary questions that often arises is "Is vinyl shake siding more expensive than other siding options?" The answer, much like the weather, isn't always clear-cut. It depends on several factors that we'll delve into to help you make an informed decision.

Vinyl shake siding, with its charming overlap design mimicking traditional wood shakes, can significantly enhance your home's curb appeal. But it's not just about appearance; you need to consider your budget, the product's longevity, and maintenance costs. Let's explore the costs and other aspects in detail.

Vinyl Shake Siding Cost Comparison

To determine if vinyl shake siding is more expensive, let's compare its cost with other popular siding options. Remember, prices can vary based on your location, the quality of the material, and installation costs.

AD
Say Goodbye to High Maintenance with Composite Cedar Shake Siding - Home Improvement DIY
Say Goodbye to High Maintenance with Composite Cedar Shake Siding - Home Improvement DIY
Why Is Vinyl Shake Better Than Cedar Shingles?
Why Is Vinyl Shake Better Than Cedar Shingles?
a light on the side of a brown building next to a white door and window
a light on the side of a brown building next to a white door and window

Vinyl shake siding typically ranges from $2 to $7 per square foot, installed. On the other hand, genuine wood shake siding, which vinyl shake siding emulates, can cost around $6 to $14 per square foot, installed. Fiber cement siding, another durable option, falls within a similar range, from $4 to $15 per square foot, installed.

Quality and Longevity

Vinyl shake siding is known for its durability and longevity, with a lifespan of 20 to 40 years. While it might seem expensive upfront, its longevity can make it a cost-effective choice in the long run.

Vacation Home Makeover with Composite Shake Siding -House Siding & Exterior Siding
Vacation Home Makeover with Composite Shake Siding -House Siding & Exterior Siding
Harbor Mill™ Shingle and Shake Siding | Faux Cedar Shake Siding
Harbor Mill™ Shingle and Shake Siding | Faux Cedar Shake Siding
Vinyl Cedar Shake Siding - Customizable and Low-Maintenance
Vinyl Cedar Shake Siding - Customizable and Low-Maintenance

Higher-quality vinyl shake siding products often come with fade-resistant warranties, ensuring your home's exterior maintains its vibrant appearance for decades. In contrast, wood siding may require periodic staining or painting and has a shorter lifespan, potentially making it less cost-effective over time.

Maintenance and Repairs

Vinyl shake siding requires little to no maintenance. Its resistance to rot, insect damage, and moisture eliminates the need for periodic painting or sealing, unlike wood siding. This can result in significant long-term savings on maintenance costs.

AD

However, vinyl siding can crack or break if subjected to extreme temperatures or impact. While these repairs are relatively simple and inexpensive, they can add to the overall cost of vinyl siding over time, depending on your home's environment and the care taken during installation.

5 Key Issue with Vinyl Cedar Shake Siding and a More Durable Alternative
5 Key Issue with Vinyl Cedar Shake Siding and a More Durable Alternative
What went wrong with our New House Exterior -
What went wrong with our New House Exterior -
How to Install Vinyl Shake Siding - Today's Homeowner
How to Install Vinyl Shake Siding - Today's Homeowner
Shake Siding: A Deep Dive on Cedar, Vinyl, & More
Shake Siding: A Deep Dive on Cedar, Vinyl, & More
Cedar Shake Vinyl Siding by The Foundry
Cedar Shake Vinyl Siding by The Foundry
3 Industry Secrets that Influence the Cost of Vinyl Siding
3 Industry Secrets that Influence the Cost of Vinyl Siding

Additional Factors Affecting Cost

Beyond the material's cost, several other factors can influence the total installation cost, making vinyl shake siding seem more expensive than other options initially. These factors include:

AD
  • Labor costs, which can be higher for more complex installation processes like those required for shake-style profiles.
  • Trim, accessories, and underlayment materials needed to complete the installation.
  • Any additional Services or materials required to prepare your home's exterior, such as referenced board replacement or flashing installation.

Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover
Coastal Style Curb Appeal with Composite Cedar Shake - Home Exterior Makeover
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding
Restoring Original Siding: Cedar Shakes + Sourcing Wood Siding
Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding
Beach House Shake’s Atlantica | Composite Cedar Shake Siding
installing vinyl stone looking siding #diy #homeimprovement #siding Changing Siding On House, How To Install Concrete Siding, Installing Concrete Siding, Easy Installation Siding Options, How To Install Vinyl Siding On Outside Corner, Faux Siding, How To Install Vinyl Siding Over Wood Siding, Diy Home Siding Installation, Gen Stone Siding
installing vinyl stone looking siding #diy #homeimprovement #siding Changing Siding On House, How To Install Concrete Siding, Installing Concrete Siding, Easy Installation Siding Options, How To Install Vinyl Siding On Outside Corner, Faux Siding, How To Install Vinyl Siding Over Wood Siding, Diy Home Siding Installation, Gen Stone Siding
How Much Does Vinyl Siding Cost?
How Much Does Vinyl Siding Cost?
TrueGrain Series™ | Hardie Shingles | Weathered Wood
TrueGrain Series™ | Hardie Shingles | Weathered Wood
NuCedar Shingles | Authentic Beauty With Lasting Performance - JAIN Building Products
NuCedar Shingles | Authentic Beauty With Lasting Performance - JAIN Building Products
Hand-Split Shake Siding: Slate Blue
Hand-Split Shake Siding: Slate Blue
How Long Does Vinyl Siding Last? A Complete Guide
How Long Does Vinyl Siding Last? A Complete Guide
Siding ideas exterior 2026 for small ranch house with vinyl siding brick walls and white porch
Siding ideas exterior 2026 for small ranch house with vinyl siding brick walls and white porch
Composite Shake Siding that Looks like Cedar - Coventry Log Homes Beach House Shake Exteriors
Composite Shake Siding that Looks like Cedar - Coventry Log Homes Beach House Shake Exteriors
The Ultimate Guide to Vinyl Siding Styles: Boost Your Home’s Curb Appeal & Value
The Ultimate Guide to Vinyl Siding Styles: Boost Your Home’s Curb Appeal & Value
Home Improvement Blog - New York Sash
Home Improvement Blog - New York Sash
2024 Summer-Season Installation: How Much Should A New Siding Cost?
2024 Summer-Season Installation: How Much Should A New Siding Cost?

Installation Complexity

Vinyl shake siding often has a more complex installation process than other siding options, which can drive up labor costs. The staggered overlap pattern reminiscent of wood shakes requires careful planning and execution to achieve the desired aesthetic and ensure proper drainage.

While vinyl shake siding is typically heavier than other types of vinyl siding, such as horizontal or vertical styles, its installation process can still be faster and more efficient due to the large size of the shake profiles, reducing material requirements and labor time.

AD

Trim and Accessories

The unique appearance of vinyl shake siding often requires specialized trim pieces and accessories to complete the installation. These items can include stackable corner posts, hipped roof pieces, and decorative accent pieces, all of which add to the overall cost.

When comparing the cost of vinyl shake siding to other options, ensure you're also considering the cost of trim and accessories necessary to create a cohesive and visually appealing exterior.

In conclusion, vinyl shake siding may seem more expensive initially, especially when considering the wider range of costs and additional factors influencing the total installation cost. However, when considering its longevity, low maintenance, and potential to increase your home's curb appeal, vinyl shake siding can be a cost-effective and valuable investment. Weigh your options carefully and consider the long-term benefits to make an informed decision that best suits your budget and your home's needs.

AD